Put out the fire any way possible
It’s a predicament with no easy answer. Should McMinnville Fire Department respond to fires outside the city limits if it’s the closest fire department?
The question is especially timely because of the fire at McMinnville Molding over the weekend. What first appeared to be a burn pile that had gotten just a little out of control turned into an inferno that has destroyed a thriving world-wide business with 55 employees.
I’ve heard some people say the fire would have never reached such devastating levels if McMinnville firefighters rushed to the scene and quickly put it out. That’s a theory I can’t validate ‘ and I certainly don’t want to undermine the efforts of volunteer firemen from the Campaign-Rock Island Fire Department who swarmed to the scene as fast as they could.
My first reaction is McMinnville should respond to fires outside the city limits, especially fires that are so close you can see the city limits sign. These are firemen for goodness sake. If there are flames, they should put them out. It’s irresponsible to sit back and let someone’s home or business burn.
After my emotions settle, the question is not so clear cut. There are policies in place, liability issues involved, and there’s also the safety of city residents to consider. If firemen are occupied with a fire outside of McMinnville, what happens if a fire breaks out inside the city?
And here’s another tidbit to ponder. Every time McMinnville officials talk about annexation and bringing more property inside the city limits, there is a lynch-mob mentality.
You’ll find most people ‘ and they are adamant about this ‘ do NOT want to be annexed into the city. It’s more taxes, they cry. Leave our property alone, they say.
Of course they forget about the extra services they’ll receive, such as McMinnville police and fire protection. Then when a fire erupts just outside the city limits they expect McMinnville to be there anyway.
After looking over the response times provided by 911, there are a couple figures which stand out. First, I’m impressed the Campaign-Rock Island Fire Department was able to get on the scene in 14 minutes. That’s pretty good for guys who were probably out shopping or doing work in the yard to spring into action and get to a fire on the edge of their district.
Second, it took McMinnville Fire Department a full 30 minutes to get on the scene after the fire was first reported to 911. That’s because, under current policy, Campaign-Rock Island has to first respond, evaluate the situation, then request mutual aid.
Since a fire doubles in size every two minutes, it certainly is easy to speculate that a loss of a business could have been prevented ‘ or at least minimized ‘ with a faster response time.
After all that babbling, here is my take. We don’t need to outsmart ourselves with too many rules and too many policies.
I fully understand the whole argument about McMinnville Fire Department operating within the city limits. But we can’t let ourselves get bogged down with so many regulations that we stop firemen from putting out fires.
We claim to have some of the brightest minds in the world in this great nation of ours. Surely we’re smart enough to realize if a building is one fire, we need to put it out.
The goal of every firefighter, whether volunteer or full-time, is to get to a fire as quickly as possible, rescue anyone inside, and extinguish the flames. I can’t support a fire department policy that enables anything other than that to take place.
James Clark is editor of the Standard. He can be reached at 473-2191 or by e-mail at [email protected].
