Mathis now faces child abuse charges – Former daycare owner must still answer to murder charges

James Rico Gore

James Rico Gore
A former daycare owner already facing murder charges was indicted Friday on seven new counts by the Warren County grand jury.
Sherri Mathis still faces first-degree murder charges for the death of 6-year-old Cheyenne Delp, a foster child in her care. Prosecutors contend Mathis strangled the girl to death.
Mathis was booked Monday at Warren County Jail for seven new child neglect and abuse charges involving Delp and two other foster children in her care.
She posted $75,000 bond in addition to the $350,000 bond she had already posted for the murder charges.
The indictments claim Mathis inflicted injury to Delp prior to her death on June 24, 2004. Specifically, the indictments claim Mathis committed child abuse against Delp between June 1 and June 24, 2004. It is also claimed Mathis committed aggravated child neglect against Delp between Oct. 1, 2001 and June 23, 2004.
The charge of child abuse pertains to direct injury. The charge of child neglect pertains to the child’s health and welfare, and possible bodily injury, as affected by improper care.
In addition to those charges, prosecutors contend Mathis committed aggravated child abuse against two boys in her care between June 16, 2003 and June 25, 2004. The boys were ages 9 and 10 at the time of Delp’s death.
Due to conflicts of interest, District Attorney Lisa Zavogiannis has recused herself from the case. Special prosecutor Brian Holmgren is handling the case. He did not return calls for comment yesterday.
Jack Lowery and Michael Galligan are handling the defense and they maintain their client’s innocence.
‘We ask the citizens of Warren County to keep an open mind since we cannot state the facts of this case at the time,’ said Galligan. ‘At trial, proof will show she did not commit these crimes.’
Mathis’ trial had been set for July 16, but the new indictments will mean a new trial date. If convicted of the murder charges, Mathis faces life in prison.
An autopsy found Delp had reportedly been strangled and her body showed evidence of abused child syndrome.
The defense contends there are questions about the cause of death and plans to produce its own experts to dispute the state’s theory. Lowery also says his client tried to save the child’s life, noting the girl suffered mental and physical problems and had suffered attacks in the past.
