Dear Margo – Good reason for divorce?
Dear Margo: I’m sure a lot of people have this moral question: Is falling out of love with your spouse reason enough to divorce?
I’ve been with my husband for 18 years, during which I’ve left him twice. We have no children and have now been separated for a year and a half, but we remain good friends. This is the basis for my confusion.
He is my best friend; I just don’t want to live with him anymore. I don’t think any amount of marriage counseling would enable me to fall in love with him again. There’s too much water under the bridge involving anger and substance abuse issues, which are the reasons I left. He refuses to address these issues. I was told to “take it or leave it,” so I left.
He has been very sweet and kind during our separation. I recognize that he is trying to woo me back, but I fear things would return to the way they were. My moral side tells me to save the marriage because I took a lifetime vow to be with him. My practical side says I won’t be happy if I go back.
I’m reluctant to give up a friendship/relationship in which I’ve invested 18 years. I’ve surveyed my married girlfriends, and none of them is happy (except one). So many people seem to stay in their marriages even if they are not happy. Is this the right thing to do?
Our friends think the world of my husband, and no one can understand why I left.
‘ No Longer in Love
Dear No: First of all, forget what the friends think. As an old expression puts it, “You never know what’s cooking in the other guy’s pot.” That said, I do find your girlfriend survey quite interesting.
I have never had much sympathy for the I-love-you-but-I’m-not-in-love-with-you position.
There is a difference, however, in being settled in a long marriage, with the fireworks muted, and being actively unhappy. I also don’t think moving in and out is any way to live. In your particular situation, it sounds like your best friend is on his best behavior when you are not under one roof. Perhaps you should keep it this way.
Your husband’s refusal to address two serious problems, in my opinion, gives you the moral right to divorce should you decide it is best for you, or should you meet someone you want to spend the rest of your life with.
‘ Margo, meditatively
Hi, Margo: I recently got engaged to the most wonderful guy, and we live together. My son’s real father wants nothing to do with him and has let him know it. (He hasn’t seen him in over a year.)
My fiance wants to adopt my son and for us to be a family. The problem is that my 5-year-old will not respect him. I have tried to have them bond and do things a kid would do with his father. My son says he “doesn’t want a daddy.” What do I do?
‘ Wanting Peace and Harmony
Dear Want: It might be useful for the little boy to talk to a child psychologist. It is quite clear that he feels his father’s rejection and probably thinks there is something wrong with him. It is understandable that he would be wary about another man in that position.
It is hard for any child to process a father’s rebuff, let alone a 5-year-old. I do think time and good guidance will solve this problem. In the meantime, tell your intended not to move in on your son in terms of showering him with attention. Proceeding gradually and subtly works well in this type of situation.
‘ Margo, unhurriedly
Dear Margo is written by Margo Howard, Ann Landers’ daughter. All letters must be sent via e-mail to [email protected]. Due to a high volume of e-mail, not all letters will be answered.
