Winkler sentence provides legitimate cause for concern
Without being the least bit negative or judgmental toward Mary Winkler, the outcome of her criminal case gives serious cause for concern about the American justice system.
A woman who confessed on the witness stand to killing her husband was found guilty and will serve a grand total of 150 days in jail for that crime.
Do the math and it doesn’t add up.
Anyone who pays regular attention to Warren County court dockets realizes some people have done more time for habitual traffic offenses. Folks have spent more time behind bars for falling behind on their child support payments.
For all the talk about the American justice system being the greatest in the world, we must remember justice is delivered on a case-by-case basis. And in any case with a jury, ‘justice’ depends on 13 people ‘ 12 jurors and one judge.
In the case of Mary Winkler, all 13 people failed to deliver justice, at least in my opinion and in the opinion of a full 80 percent of the people who responded to the Standard’s online poll.
The jury was first at fault for convicting Winkler of voluntary manslaughter ‘ an enormous break considering she admitted to shooting a sleeping man in the back. But even at this point there was a chance to make Winkler pay a significant price for her crime.
According to sentencing guidelines, Judge Weber McCraw could have given Winkler up to six years in prison. And killing a defenseless man certainly qualified Winkler for the upper spectrum in the sentencing guidelines.
Even with time off for good behavior, and taking into account the 143 days she already served in jail, a year and a half in prison would have not been a pleasure cruise for Winkler. It would have at least sent some semblance of a message.
By giving Winkler seven more days in jail, Judge McCraw also failed to deliver justice.
Of broader concern is the painful fact that someone who could have arguably been eligible for the death penalty was able to kill another human being, get caught red-handed, and receive a grand total of five months for the crime. It’s disturbing.
Granted, not everyone would have the luxury of high-powered lawyers working for free, but what would happen if all confessed killers received five months in jail? It would completely rule out jail time as a deterrent for murder because anyone can handle five months in the county jail.
Whether you supported Mary Winkler or supported a stiff sentence, the bigger picture is our justice system. A killer has been tried and convicted. All law-abiding citizens should demand more than 150 days in jail for such a crime.
