Skip to content

Where was proof in Cooper trial?

When the prosecution rested in the federal case against state Sen. Jerry Cooper on the second day of trial, there was one word which came to mind. WHAT?

I’ve sat through a lot of cases in my 17 years here, but I’ve got to say this one wasn’t even close. While it was reported the jury deliberated for 45 minutes, the reality is that if you subtract time for walking to and from the jury room, getting settled and then the time it took to get back to the courtroom and round up the participants, I’d say they deliberated all of 15 minutes, with the first poll probably being unanimous to acquit the senator and the other 14 minutes spent sitting around small talking.

The bottom line is there was never any evidence of an intent or an conspiracy to defraud the bank. What I think happened from listening to all the evidence was Jerry Cooper asked local appraiser Jimmy Passons to do an assessment on his Smartt Station property and to include a rail spur which I firmly believe the lawmaker thought would be there in short order.

I base this on testimony from two of our county executives along with other state officials who said the funding had been approved to build the rail spur in question but it was only stopped when Tony Auyer, the man who started the investigation, got caught pilfering government property.

Even if you can somehow, in the light best to the prosecution, convince yourself this was evidence to defraud the bank, you have to consider there was no evidence Cooper ever coerced Passons to write the report the way he suggested. There’s not even evidence Passons was paid for the work.

As for allegations against Lt. Gov. John Wilder, suggesting he used his influence to help Cooper get the loan in one of his banks, he may have tried to do his colleague a favor by getting one of his banks to look at it, but let’s face it, this veteran banker isn’t going to risk $1.7 million on his own mother. A favor is one thing, kissing away that much coin is something else. Auyer got the loan because they put up more collateral. That’s what the evidence showed.

And speaking of Auyer, how in the world can you go to trial without calling any of the alleged co-conspirators when you’re trying a conspiracy case? Tony Auyer, not there. Wayne Rogers, the man who mysteriously pushed the loan without ever checking the assessment, not there. Bill Baxter, former commissioner under Gov. Don Sundquist, the man prosecutors said owed Cooper a favor and pushed the government-insured loan, not there. I think everyone in that courtroom was wanting to know what these folks had to say.

And, the ones who were there all testified, to a man, that no one ever put any pressure on them to make the loan. Where’s the case?

Last week I said Cooper should testify. I still stand by that statement seeing the failure of key prosecution witnesses to testify had the same effect, causing jurors to wonder what prosecutors had to hide by not calling these alleged key players in the grand conspiracy. In this case the defense figured, correctly, the prosecution had no chance so Cooper was not put on.

Given the one-sided victory, I have to wonder how no one saw this coming. Jerry Cooper to criminal prosecution is what ‘Ishtar’ (Google it youngsters) is to movies ‘ the biggest bomb in memory. Couldn’t anyone see this coming in preparation for the trial, or was everyone afraid to speak up?

At least witch hunts have some direction. This was more like a snipe hunt where the fictional character never existed, leaving the taxpayers standing there holding the bag for this case.

Duane Sherrill is a reporter for the Standard. He can be reached at 473-2191 or by e-mail at [email protected].

Leave a Comment