Skip to content

Winkler gets 7 days in jail – She could be out Friday

Mary Winkler could be out of jail in time for next weekend after she was sentenced Friday in Selmer by Judge Weber McCraw.

The sentence calls for Winkler to serve seven more days in jail.

McCraw handed Winkler a three-year sentence for killing her husband as he slept, but ruled she only had to serve 210 days. Considering Winkler gets credit for the 143 days she has already served in jail, that leaves 67 days.

McCraw then said Winkler could serve up to 60 of those 67 days in a mental health facility ‘ not jail.

‘Of course it’s a victory,’ said one of Winkler’s attorneys, Steve Farese. ‘She could be in prison for life, and that’s what everybody thought she was headed for to begin with.’

Winkler faced first-degree murder charges but was convicted of voluntary manslaughter by a 10-woman, two-man jury. Voluntary manslaughter carries a sentencing guideline of three to six years.

Local attorney Bernard Smith, who has 48 years of courtroom experience, says the sentence is extremely lenient.

‘I think it’s a miscarriage of justice,’ said Smith. ‘She did the deed and the jury found her guilty. This sends a bad message. Some of these judges are making a joke of the legal system.’

Smith said he doesn’t believe Winkler deserves the lightest possible sentence because she did nothing to save husband Matthew Winkler’s life after she shot him.

‘She just left,’ said Smith. ‘She didn’t call 911 or anything. Even hours later, she didn’t stop and call 911.’

McCraw could have granted Winkler a judicial diversion, which would have allowed the charges to be erased from her record, or he could have given her a completely suspended sentence that would have allowed her to walk out of the courtroom Friday as a free woman.

‘I ask for mercy and understanding, but I know whatever decision you reach today will be right,’ Mary Winkler said, reading a statement from a yellow legal pad. ‘I ask you to please let me go home today and be with my children.’

She turned to her husband’s family and told them she was ‘so sorry this has happened.’ She said she understood they were angry with her and that she prayed every night for them to have peace.

‘I think of Matthew every day, and I’ll always miss him and love him,’ she said.

Speaking to the judge, Winkler said, ‘Whatever sentence you give me can never punish me enough. I’ve suffered the loss of someone I loved. I’ve lost my freedom. I’ve lost my children, and I’ve had my life put on public display.’

Speaking to the public, Winkler said, ‘I hope this situation sheds light on unhealthy relationships, and that others will find the strength and have the courage to seek help before such a tragedy occurs again. I always tried to go to him to get help, and I wasn’t strong enough to do that for him. And, I think of that every day, that I feel like I failed him by not being able to help.’

While Friday’s sentencing brought an end to Winkler’s criminal charges, it likely won’t be the last time she appears in court. A legal battle is expected between Winkler and her former in-laws, Dan and Diane Winkler, over custody of Mary Winkler’s three children.

The Associated Press and Jackson Sun contributed to this report.

Leave a Comment