Skip to content

We can’t hire who we want

Two women have won a gender discrimination lawsuit against the company that owns our local Taco Bell and a total of 82 Taco Bell franchises across the South.

In simplest terms, the verdict says that MRCO, the company that owns the 82 Taco Bells, didn’t hire enough women for upper management positions. Thus MRCO was ordered to pay the two women who filed the lawsuit over $90,000, and in all likelihood the company will have to find more estrogen to fill chairs at corporate headquarters.

My gripe (and you knew I had to have one) is this ruling seems to go against the great American way. In this fine nation we have seemingly endless freedoms. We can say what we want, worship how we please, even amass a large arsenal of semi-automatic weapons if we so desire.

But when it comes to hiring employees and promoting them up the corporate ladder, the government can step in and tell us we have broken the law because we don’t have the right men-women ratio in upper management. It seems intrusive. It seems wrong. It seems like something that would happen in a Third World country struggling for freedom.

Let me break it down this way. Let’s say I have a few odd jobs I want done around the house. Since I’m the person paying for this work, I have the right to determine who to hire. If I want to hire Bob, that’s my choice. If I want to hire Nancy, that’s fine too. After all, this is America.

So let’s say I have a small company with a workforce of about 25. I certainly wouldn’t discriminate when it comes to hiring but let’s say, hypothetically speaking, I wanted to hire 25 women because I get along better and work better with women.

It’s my company, my payroll and my money. Therefore, it should be my choice to hire whoever I want as long as I’m paying the bills.

But wait ‘ I can’t. If I don’t have the perfect mix of men and women in my workforce, I can get taken to court and ordered to pay some ridiculous settlement.

The recent lawsuit is not a nice way to say thanks to a company that owns 82 Taco Bell restaurants and provides thousands of jobs to people throughout the South. Admittedly, they’re not high-paying industrial jobs, but they’re jobs nonetheless.

On top of that, based on information provided by the two female plaintiffs, 60 percent of the 82 Taco Bell store managers are women. That shows the company certainly has equality in mind when it comes to promoting at individual stores.

But the so-called problem comes from the upper level where only 15 percent of the corporate employees are women. The total corporate breakdown in this case is 19 men and three women, which doesn’t seem lawsuit worthy if you ask me.

My point is when we’re talking about private businesses in the land of the free, they should be free to hire who they want. There shouldn’t be government quotas mandating that a certain segment of the population be on the payroll in high places. The next thing you know, government officials will have the final say on wallpaper decisions at the office.

Just like I have the right to decide who I pay to fix my car, and who I pay to cut my hair, companies in this country should be able to pay whoever they want to fill positions on their workforce. To say otherwise, in my mind, goes against the American way.

James Clark is editor of the Standard. He can be reached at 473-2191 or by e-mail at [email protected].

Leave a Comment