Skip to content

Cooper should take the stand

One word of advice for state Sen. Jerry Cooper. TESTIFY!

Yes, jurors do hold it against if you if you don’t testify in your own behalf, even though the judge may tell them not to until he is blue in the face. Fact is, if a person is innocent, it’s only human nature for jurors to want the person to look them in the eye and tell them they didn’t do it.

Granted, the law says no one has to testify when they are on trial if they do not wish. And, yes, it is your right. However, I’ve seen this backfire scores of times when a defense team decides the state hasn’t proved its case and decides to let the jury go into deliberations without hearing from the defendant. What happens in these cases is if the case is marginal, jurors start wondering to themselves what the defendant had to hide. In a toss up, it’s the difference between innocence and guilt.

The problem is that sometimes, out of caution, an attorney will advise his or her client not to testify, fearing the person may come across badly on the stand. The defense sometimes fears the cross examination, worrying facts could come to light to make the situation even worse. Most post-conviction appeals claiming ineffective assistance of counsel point to their attorneys talking them out of testifying. The client usually regrets not testifying. Of course this is in hindsight after their conviction.

Sure, there are some clients who shouldn’t be put on the stand. Those who are psychotic or those who have a grandiose opinion of themselves can sometimes talk themselves into a jail cell. Those who are guilty as the day is long should also think twice since it’s hard to keep 1,000 lies straight under the glare of the jury.

In the case of Jerry Cooper, the jury will want to hear it from his own mouth. Right now we know he asked local appraiser Jimmy Passons to write up the appraisal of his land to wrongly say it contained a rail spur, making it worth much more than it would without it. However, asking someone to do this with the intent of actually having the rail placed there is a lot different than asking them to do it and never intending to put the rail in.

It’s either a mistake in judgment, or straight out fraud. There is no middle ground. However, last time I looked, a mistake of judgment was not a crime seeing fraud requires an intent to do something wrong.

Right now, the case is teetering and is up in the air, the way I see it. Just listening to the evidence, we know there were things done that should not have been done. There were some real errors in judgment by many people, not just Cooper.

With that said, I think the key will be Jerry Cooper getting on the stand, looking the jurors in the eye, admitting he made a mistake in judgment but at the same time, telling them he never meant to defraud anyone. People will forgive a mistake if it’s admitted. They may not forgive refusing to testify seeing it leaves too many questions swirling around in their heads when the jury door closes for deliberation.

I’m not an attorney and don’t even play one on TV, but if it was me in a similar situation, I’d insist on taking the stand, especially if I was good enough with people that I’d been elected over and over to the legislature. Choosing to exercise your right not to testify often means you will be choosing your time to exercise in the prison exercise yard in the near future. When in doubt, testify.

Duane Sherrill is a reporter for the Standard. He can be reached at 473-2191 or by e-mail at [email protected].

Leave a Comment