Skip to content

Former minister’s appeal denied – Convicted child molester claims counsel failed him

Serving 48 years in prison for molesting an 8-year-old girl, former Gath Baptist youth minister Jeffery Simmons failed to get relief this week when Circuit Court Judge Bart Stanley turned down his request for new trial with Simmons vowing to appeal his case to the top.

Citing the law, dates and names off the top of his head without ever glancing at a note, Simmons, who works as a law clerk in the prison where he resides, painted a picture of conspiracy and legal mistakes which has left him locked behind bars for seven years since his arrest for inappropriate contact with underage girls, many of whom attended the church where he was youth minister. Simmons is charged with inappropriate contact with five youths; however, he is presently convicted in one case, that being the fondling of an 8-year-old while the girl was spending nights with his daughter in their family home. Simmons won a hung jury in another case regarding a 12-year-old girl who said he solicited sex with her.

As for his conviction, Simmons maintained ineffective assistance of counsel in the case of the public defender’s office, saying they failed to call many witnesses to the stand and that they failed to press the young victim on inconsistencies in her story.

‘She just made up answers as she went,’ Simmons testified this week before Judge Stanley, saying the victim’s testimony at trial differed from her original claims of molestation. The girl told the court Simmons had rubbed her private area during trial; however, Simmons said the girl originally said he rubbed her leg.

‘I’m serving 48 years for rubbing a girl’s leg four times,’ Simmons told the court, noting there were 66 topics in which the girl had changed her story.

In addition to saying his counsel failed to pursue the girl’s inconsistent statements, Simmons also said he should have never been tried in Warren County, noting there was too much information available in the media for prospective jurors.

‘The newspapers condemned me before trial,’ Simmons said. ‘There was no possible way I could have received a fair trial in Warren County.’

In addition to questioning the actions of his attorneys, Simmons also questioned the actions of Judge Stanley, revealing he had seen the judge standing on the front steps of the courthouse following his conviction in 2003, chatting with prosecution witness Gath Minister Ray Gilder.

Simmons said the friendship between judge and witness should have led to Stanley’s recusal, noting Gilder provided damaging testimony against him, telling the court of his marital woes which he had entrusted the minister with. Those problems, Simmons said, soured the jury against him.

‘Just because I had marital problems does not make me a child molester,’ Simmons said.

In addition to the aforementioned issues, Simmons said his counsel talked him out of testifying in his own behalf, saying he wished he had not listened to them now.

‘I knew I had to testify to prove my innocence or they would believe that child,’ Simmons said in hindsight.

With the denial of his motion for new trial, Simmons will take his case before the state court of criminal appeals. There is no word on when he will face trial on his other charges.

Leave a Comment