Shooting may have been accident, lawyer suggests – Jury selection has questions about abuse, gun accidents
SELMER, Tenn. ? Defense attorneys for a preacher?s wife accused of killing her husband questioned potential jurors Tuesday about whether they had ever been in abusive relationships and if they thought guns could accidentally discharge.
The line of questioning suggests defense attorneys for Mary Winkler may try to argue during the first-degree murder trial that she had been abused and that the shooting was an accident.
?Does anyone disagree that firearms can be discharged accidentally, or unintentionally?? defense attorney Steve Farese asked. ?Do you agree with me that it?s not unusual for many women not to know how to load a firearm??
Matthew Winkler, a popular 31-year-old preacher at the Fourth Street Church of Christ in Selmer, was found fatally wounded from a shotgun blast in the church parsonage in March 2006. His wife was arrested one day later some 340 miles away on the Alabama coast with their three young daughters.
Wearing a cross around her neck, Mary Winkler, 33, sat at a table Tuesday with her four lawyers in the small courtroom. She watched jury selection intently and took notes.
Defense attorney Leslie Ballin asked if jurors had been in or knew of someone in an abusive relationship, believed domestic abuse was a real problem, and if they knew about the life of a preacher?s wife.
?Do we all agree there are family secrets that just aren?t talked about?? Ballin asked Tuesday. ?Ministers? wives live a different kind of life, don?t they? They don?t really have anyone to talk to.?
Both sides released their witness lists Tuesday. The prosecution has 14 people as potential witnesses, while the defense list has 43 names, including the sheriff who drove to Alabama after Mary Winkler?s arrest and brought her back to Selmer, a small town 80 miles east of Memphis.
Police have said Winkler admitted killing her husband last year, and that it had something to do with his constant criticism.
?It was just building up to this point,? Winkler said, according to a statement taken by Alabama police. ?I was just tired of it. I guess I just got to a point and snapped.?
Lawyers will select Winkler?s jury from a pool of about 160 McNairy County residents.
The potential jurors questioned so far include a woman who lived near the Winklers who has been interviewed by the media. When asked in court if she knew Matthew, the woman said he had once threatened to shoot her dog if it didn’t stay out of his yard. The woman said she told Matthew that she would try to keep the dog in her yard. She didn’t think the incident would prevent her from being an impartial juror.
Other potential jurors included a Baptist minister and a man who belongs to the Church of Christ. The minister expressed a concern he had during court.
?I?m a minister, and I just don’t feel right passing down judgment on somebody else,? the man said.
Assistant District Attorney General Walter Freeland asked him if he thought that would keep him from being a fair juror for the state. He said it wouldn’t.
?I could be if it?s put on me,? the minister said. ?But I?d rather not be? a juror.
Defense attorneys also asked potential jurors about their religious affiliations and familiarity with firearms.
While Winkler has been found competent to stand trial, her attorneys have indicated they may argue that she lacked the required state of mind to commit premeditated first-degree murder.
Farese pointed out to potential jurors that the important question wasn?t whether they?d heard of the case but whether they?d formed an opinion about it.
?I think all of you at one time or another have formed some kind of opinion,? Farese said. ?We can?t live in a vacuum. These things happen. My question is simply this: Can you set aside those opinions and come through those doors and sit in this box and give Mrs. Winkler … Look at me, Mary … a fair trial just like you would want one of your loved ones to receive? Can you do that? That?s all I want to hear.?
Some of the questions lawyers asked were general, such as whether potential jurors believed they’d give more weight to a police officer?s testimony over a layperson?s.
Other questions were more specific to the case. For instance, they were asked whether they thought it was OK to lie to children to protect them from something hurtful. One juror didn’t think that was OK. She indicated that she believed in telling children the truth.
According to statements the Winkler children gave police, after the shooting Mary told the children that a bad man had robbed them and their father was in the hospital.
Police have said Mary then left the parsonage and drove to Jackson, Miss., with the couple?s three young girls. She had been headed to Baton Rouge, where the Winklers used to live, but had changed her mind by the next day and headed instead for Orange Beach, Ala. She was taken into custody March 23, 2006, in Orange Beach following a traffic stop.
According to the children?s statements to police, Mary also told her girls that she?d brought a gun with them on the trip to protect them from the bad man.
Other questions were about whether jurors have had any experience with domestic abuse. Members of Mary?s family have said they saw signs that Matthew physically and emotionally abused her, and her attorneys have said allegations of abuse will come out in the trial.
One potential juror indicated that her daughter had been a victim in a longtime abusive marriage that finally ended in divorce.
