Edwards family pushes forward
After learning that her breast cancer had returned, Elizabeth Edwards told “60 Minutes,” “Either you push forward with the things that you were doing yesterday or you start dying.”
Every family in America has been touched by cancer, including ours. And we believe strongly that all of them have the right to handle the disease in their own way. So we resent critics who pass moral judgment on the Edwards family.
Elizabeth Edwards gets to live — and die — according to her own moral code.
Edwards himself framed the issue on “60 Minutes”: “I think every single candidate for president … have personal lives that indicate something about what kind of human being they are, and I think it is a fair evaluation for America to engage in …”
Some say we’ve learned that Edwards is ruthlessly ambitious, and that’s probably true. But we’ve also learned that he can handle stress and make hard decisions under pressure, and those qualities would make him a better president.
From the beginning, stories that illuminate “the kind of human being” who’s running for president have been part of our politics. Americans have always looked for candidates who demonstrate honesty, bravery and above all, the tenacity to triumph over adversity. Think George Washington surviving Valley Forge, Abe Lincoln growing up in a log cabin. But television, which feeds and focuses on personalities, has placed a higher premium than ever on heroic narratives.
The first president of the TV age, Dwight Eisenhower, led American troops into battle on D-Day. The highpoint of John F. Kennedy’s story was the sinking of his naval craft, PT-109 (the boat became the symbol of his campaign and aging New Frontiersmen still wear PT-109 tie clasps in his honor).
George Bush the Elder flew 58 combat missions during World War II and was shot down over the Pacific. Bill Clinton became The Boy from Hope, the son of a no-account father who died before he was born and a courageous mother who needed his protection from an abusive new husband.
George W. Bush was just another privileged and spoiled child before his wife, Laura, helped him conquer alcohol and find religion. That story of salvation helped him beat Al Gore (who lacked any compelling narrative) and John Kerry (who had two storylines that conflicted with each other, combat veteran and antiwar protestor).
In the current field, John McCain obviously tells the richest tale of heroism. Among Edwards’ competitors for the Democratic nomination, Hillary Clinton is developing a narrative that portrays her as a “middle class” daughter born in “middle America” in the “middle of the last century.”
Clinton can’t talk about the part of her life that has required the most resilience: putting up with her wayward husband. The real power of her story has to come from the campaign itself — her drive to be the first woman president.
Barack Obama’s highlight reel is also more about his future — as the first black president — than about his past. He’s often compared to John F. Kennedy, and his tale of growing up in a mixed race family is certainly engaging. But has he really been tested by tragedy or crisis? Kennedy, at his age, had already survived Japanese guns, a serious illness and searing daily pain.
The odds are strongly against John Edwards becoming president. But he and his wife have passed a key test. In the face of tragedy they have not started dying. They have continued to live, and work, and “push forward.”
Steve and Cokie Roberts can be contacted by e-mail at [email protected].
