Should state limit malpractice payouts?
A Warren County jury awarded a local family $4.2 million last month for what it considered negligence on the part of NHC in McMinnville.
In 2006, a local jury ordered River Park Hospital to pay $7.2 million in a wrongful death lawsuit.
With medical malpractice lawsuits soaring in Tennessee, and throughout the nation, should state legislators put a cap on monetary damages? It?s a question members of the Tennessee General Assembly are kicking around this legislative session.
?I think the awards are too much and they have a tendency to get higher and higher,? said state Rep. Judd Matheny. ?I don?t want to diminish anybody?s rights to get what they deserve through the court system. Enough money does need to be awarded to settle bills of the family. But at the same time, we don?t want to run companies out of business.?
A proposal in the legislature would set a cap on non-economic awards such as pain and suffering at $250,000 against medical practitioners and $250,000 against health care facilities.
It would not cap awards for economic damages, which account for lost wages and medical treatment.
In the NHC case, the jury?s $4.2 million award was for pain and suffering and other damages. If the proposal before the legislature was in effect, that $4.2 million would be reduced to a maximum of $500,000.
State Rep. Charles Curtiss says such huge monetary awards only serve to drive up the cost of health care for everyone.
?That $4 million might be great for the family but everybody who goes to the doctor for the next 20 years is going to be paying for it,? said Curtiss. ?It?s not like that money comes out of thin air.
?If the doctor is grossly negligent, the money should come out of his pocket,? added Curtiss. ?But there are so many frivolous lawsuits and we need to curb that.?
The medical profession is desperately seeking relief from such exorbitant lawsuit awards. Meanwhile an equally powerful entity, trial lawyers, don?t want any limits placed on lawsuit amounts.
Both sides point to statistics to support their arguments.
Dr. Michael Minch, vice chairman of the Tennessee Medical Association Board of Trustees, says 87 percent of claims in this state result in no payout to plaintiffs. Yet these lawsuits still cost millions to defend, Minch says, and that cost is passed on to all patients.
John A. Day is a Brentwood attorney who represents medical malpractice victims. Day says that government-funded studies indicate nearly 2,000 Tennesseans die as a result of medical malpractice each year. Thousands more are injured. But he says only 465 Tennesseans received settlements in malpractice cases in 2005, and that number was only 444 in 2004.
Day contends medical mistakes are being buried ? literally.
While lawmakers are considering possible options, Curtiss says don?t expect any action this year.
?Nothing significant is going to happen until the public really gets in an uproar,? said Curtiss. ?The Judiciary Committee is generally controlled by trial lawyers and they?re not going to let anything get out of there unless there?s public outcry.?
Matheny agrees.
?This is a very important issue to a lot of people,? Matheny said. ?It?s going to have to take up the majority of time in a future session of the General Assembly.?
