Skip to content

Aldermen not ready to name Rutherford city administrator – Last-minute applicant given Friday interview

Johnny Williams out of Tuscaloosa, Ala., has put the brakes on what could have been the end of the McMinnville?s search for a city administrator.

This Johnny-come-lately has put everything on hold, but does he have the qualifications to beat out David Rutherford? Williams? application was received at city hall after the deadline, but it had the appropriate postmark so he is officially in the running.

After reviewing the six new applicants for the city administrator job, Finance Committee members Bobby Kirby, Donald Hillis and Patti Nunley have unanimously agreed to interview Williams because of his promising application and a little ?fact-finding mission? by Hillis when he called Williams.

?I went on a fact-finding mission and here are the facts,? said Hillis. ?He has been unemployed since December 2006. At that time, his contract ran out and after going back and forth a little bit he said ?I?m going to the house,? and he did. I liked this guy. He was real pleasant to talk to.?

According to Hillis, Williams has nothing to keep him from moving to Tennessee immediately. His children are grown and living in different parts of the country. His mother, although ill at this time, is within driving distance from here.

Of interest, Hillis also asked Williams what his beginning and ending pay was for his last position and the response was also promising. After commenting on it and divulging the numbers to other elected officials, everyone seemed to agree that his price range is well within what McMinnville is offering.

Also making the short list of acceptable applicants is David Rutherford and David Mitchell out of Temple, Texas.

Rutherford has already gone through the interview process so it won?t be necessary to interview him again. As for Mitchell, he has applied for the position all three times and has not been given strong consideration due to his lack of experience.

Lack of experience might not be negative, according to one alderman. Nunley thinks elected officials should look at it more as a plus.

?Instead of getting someone down here to tell us how they have done it forever, we could get someone who wants to come here and make this place as good as everyone else has got,? said Nunley. ?The fact they haven?t been in the business forever, to me, isn?t necessarily bad.?

The generally accepted route to success for city administrators is to move to larger and better-paying cities as a way to advance, but hiring someone with experience doesn?t mean they will stick with McMinnville.

?I think there are arguments to both sides,? said Nunley. ?He has some experience in government. We haven?t given him much consideration in the past and I think we might be making a mistake.?

Given that, Mitchell?s application will be placed on hold. The remaining three applicants were all eliminated from consideration.

After a quick call to Williams by Mayor Royce Davenport, he will be in McMinnville for a formal interview Friday at 4:30 p.m. If possible, he will arrive early to look around McMinnville and stay until Saturday.

Leave a Comment