My Turn – Barack and Hillary duel in Dixie
Last Sunday, I watched the two leading ?dueling Democrats? go at it again, this time in two separate black churches in Selma, Ala.
Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton squared off, not at a few paces, but about three blocks apart. Affecting their best, but terribly transparent, Southern accents, they seized on the 42nd anniversary of the famous 1965 Selma civil rights march to court black voters in their respective quests for the White House.
Sen. Obama wowed the friendly crowd with his message of humility and hope.?In terms of content, organization and delivery, it was clear to me he had really done his homework, especially in analyzing his audience and honing his message to resonate with them.?He spoke eloquently and passionately about the need to continue the work begun by Martin Luther King Jr., and others.
He also challenged black Americans to quit blaming others for their oppression and look within themselves for strength and inspiration to succeed.?He emphasized the importance of taking personal responsibility in child-bearing and child-raising, the necessity of getting a good education, and the need for positive black role models. Moreover, he urged blacks to ?get out and vote.?
All in all, I thought Sen. Obama connected well with his audience and communicated a positive, upbeat message.?His charisma and oratorical skills were on full display, and apparently well-received by his immediate audience. Whether his speech and his candidacy for president are well-received by his larger national audience remains to be seen.
As for Sen. Clinton?s speech, I found it stilted, and at times, downright shrill.?In terms of content and organization, it was adequate, but in terms of delivery, it paled in comparison to Sen. Obama?s presentation.?
Apparently, Sen. Clinton thinks she can raise the level of dialogue by raising the level of her voice.?To a point, she is right.? Vocal variety is a good thing. Raising and lowering your voice for effect can enhance your message.?However, last Sunday she raised the decibel level to Howard Dean loudness several times ??not a good thing because it could saddle her image, as it did his, with a new nickname.?
Remember ?Deaniac?? How about ?Shrillary?? That may sound a little harsh, but it is catchy and descriptive of some of her remarks.?I offer it freely to my vast reading audience, knowing it will cause some to chuckle and others to cringe.
On a more substantive level, I thought Sen. Clinton tended to play the race and victim cards in her speech, conjuring up images of unequal access to voting polls for blacks and nefarious attempts to mislead them as to times and places for voting.?
This is eerily reminiscent of her ?vast right-wing conspiracy theories,? espoused in response to the impeachment charges against President Clinton.?That part of her message may have played well with some of her immediate audience, but I predict this kind of pandering will backfire on her with the larger national audience.
Stay tuned for the next round of ?Dueling Democrats.?
Thomas B. Vaughn is an instructor at Motlow College and co-host of the radio show ?Viewpoints,? which airs on WCPI 91.3 FM.
