Guest Editorial – Government doesn?t need more secrecy
This week is Sunshine Week, but Tennesseans, already victims of some of the weakest open government laws in the country, will have little to celebrate. A legislative panel created last spring to produce recommended reforms for the current session got sandbagged by House and Senate leaders, who neglected to appoint key members until last fall. As a result, the panel then deferred until 2008 the reform recommendations that it was originally supposed to provide last month for the current session to consider.
Meanwhile, the states Sunshine Law is likely to come under new attacks this session by lobbyists intent on diluting last years revised ethics bill, and by the Ethics Commission itself with regard to rules on its communications.
This is a shameful counterpoint to Sunshine Week. The national observance was begun in 2002 to prompt discussion about the importance of open government and to spur improvements to state laws mandating transparency in government. Its ironic that state lawmakers blatantly ignore reform and, instead, go backwards. This dismal condition illustrates precisely how little legislators and city and county leaders around the state care about strengthening the states open government laws.
The Legislature, in fact, has long exempted its work from the Sunshine Law. Other public officials who are supposed to operate under the open government rules like the law weak, enforcement difficult, and penalties toothless. Many state and local public officials and agency heads would prefer expanded exemptions and have lobbied for weaker rules, not stronger ones.
Tennesseans should be appalled. Tennessee ranked 45th in the nation last year on open government standards. The reforms proposed last year by the Tennessee Coalition for Open Government (TCOG) are sensible and straight-forward. They easily could be packaged into legislation this session and adopted, if lawmakers cared enough about Tennesseans right to know what their various governmental bodies are doing. Under Tennessees open records and meetings law, public business is to be conducted publicly, and all public records are to be made available to citizens upon request. Meetings of public bodies are to be advertised in advance and open to the public. Public business is not to be deliberated upon by public officials except in publicly called meetings.
Yet violations of such provisions are routine. Audits conducted by TCOG show that public officials ? sheriffs, planning commissions, police departments, and other public agencies ? deny about a third of citizens requests for information and records that they are legally required to meet.
Members of county commissions, city councils and other public bodies often discuss public business privately beforehand, deliberating toward, and in many cases reaching, decisions that are then made publicly without discussion. That leaves citizens uninformed of the basis for such decisions. The consequence of the occasional lawsuit, if any, is an order to redo a contested vote in public.
Tennessees Open Meetings Act clearly needs revision. TCOG recommendations would establish clearer rules and definitions for open meeting requirements, more tightly defined exemptions, and fines and penalties for violations. Citizens who successfully sue to rescind decisions made illegally would have their legal costs reimbursed.
TCOG also advocates broadening of the law to include private entities and non-profits with respect to their delivery of public services. Its also would account for advances in electronic communications ? e-mails, text messages and simultaneous communications ? that now make nonpublic communications regarding public business easy.
Unfortunately, these recommendations are not likely to see the light of day in discussions on the floor of the Legislature this year. Too few legislators care about making government more transparent. They, and the local officials they protect, simply had rather evade public accountability. That is shameful.
