NCAA committee has tough decisions at top of bracket
They?re likely to spend the next week hearing everyone complain about it.
Welcome to life as chairman of the highest-profile committee in college athletics, where the only thing everyone seems to agree on is that nobody gets it right.
?Having observed the criticism over the years from teams that didn?t get in, I understand how difficult that is,? said Walters, the athletic director at Princeton. ?We?re aware there will be some teams that are disappointed, so you have to have thick enough skin to handle it.?
While people like Walters often find themselves explaining the committee?s decisions, it?s not as if they have exclusive rights on being targeted. Remember 2004, when Saint Joseph?s received a No. 1 seed and CBS commentator Billy Packer told a national television audience it was too high? Saint Joseph?s coach Phil Martelli fired back by questioning Packer?s credentials, and his Hawks eventually advanced to the regional finals before losing to Oklahoma State.
For the 10-member voting bloc meeting in Indianapolis this week, the decisions could be even tougher. Aside from choosing who?s in and who?s out, they must also decipher a seeding process that appears nearly as jumbled at the top as it does on the bottom.
With Florida?s late-season struggles, Wisconsin?s injuries and Kansas? less-than-spectacular power ranking, Walters acknowledged Wednesday that they?ll also be watching scores from this week?s conference tournaments to sort out the mess.
?There?s no magic formula to this,? Walters said. ?Just because a team has a solid record or is solid in league play or even has a .500 record in league play isn?t enough. You have the unbalanced schedules, so some teams may have followed a different path.?
Among those fighting for No. 1 seeds are Florida and Wisconsin.
The Gators (26-5) are the defending national champions, the regular-season Southeastern Conference champs and were ranked No. 1 as recently as four weeks ago. But consecutive losses at LSU and Tennessee, before beating Kentucky at home last weekend, knocked the Gators down to No. 6 in The Associated Press poll and No. 9 in the RPI Index, a calculation that includes victories over Division I opponents, strength of schedule and opponents? strength of schedule.
Wisconsin (27-4) finds itself in a different predicament. The Badgers are No. 3 in the poll and No. 4 in the NCAA?s RPI ratings, but haven?t been the same since starting center Brian Butch went down with a right elbow injury during a oss to No. 1 Ohio State.
