Family criticizes murder trial delays – Grandparents contend three years long enough to wait
The family of a 6-year-old girl allegedly murdered by the woman in charge of her care wants to know why it has taken nearly three years for the case to come to trial.
The court date for former daycare owner Sherri Mathis is now set for July 16 when she is due to stand trial for the death of her ward of the court, Cheyenne Delp, who died under mysterious circumstances on June 26, 2004 at their Kings Point home.
Delp and her two brothers had been in the care of Mathis for some time leading up to the child?s death, which prosecutors say the autopsy suggests came due to strangulation. The defense maintains the child suffered physical problems and died from a pre-existing medical condition, noting Mathis attempted to save the child?s life when she found her lifeless that day.
Prosecutors are seeking life without chance of parole. Mathis has been free on bond since shortly after her arrest on the first-degree murder charge.
The trial date set for July is the fourth trial date the case has been assigned as it was originally set to be held Sept. 19, 2005.
?Our case has been postponed three different times, with months in between,? wrote Delp?s grandparents Mr. and Mrs. Earl Delp in a letter to Circuit Court Judge Bart Stanley, urging him to make sure the case now goes on its appointed date. ?Our family is still not getting on with our lives due to little Cheyenne?s death not being explained, justified or punished.?
The case was continued from its original date until Feb. 11, 2006 due to a debate over the medical records of Delp?s two brothers, who were also in the care of Mathis at the time of the girl?s death. The debate continued on, forcing yet another continuance until June 5, 2006, falling in the middle of election season.
?The prosecutor (then-District Attorney Dale Potter) told us nothing would be done before election,? the grandparents told the judge. ?And he did lose.?
With the election of present District Attorney Lisa Zavogiannis came a conflict of interest as she had been involved in representing the Delp children civilly in the past so she had to recuse herself from the case, leading to the assignment of a special prosecutor.
Tory Johnson of Nashville is now prosecuting the case which Judge Stanley has said he wants to hear on its present date in July.
?Our time is moving not stopping,? the grandparents told the judge. ?Cheyenne?s brothers? time and lives are moving, not stopping. Cheyenne?s mom and dad?s time is moving not stopping.?
In addition to her criminal case, Mathis is being sued by Delp?s mother, Roxanne Haga, for the wrongful death of her daughter.
