Skip to content

Aldermen meet in secret to discuss hiring Rutherford

The sun isn?t shining bright in McMinnville and even the Sunshine Law seems to be dimming.

One year after meeting secretly to oust former city administrator Herb Llewellyn, McMinnville aldermen are conducting city business behind closed doors again.

This time it isn?t an effort to get a city administrator out, but to get one in.

At Tuesday night?s Board of Mayor and Aldermen meeting, Alderman Rick Barnes made a motion for Mayor Royce Davenport to notify Glenn Abee that he is no longer being considered for city administrator. That motion was seconded by Bobby Kirby.

Alderman Jimmy Haley questioned why this motion was made and seconded, since it would leave the city without an applicant. In response, Kirby said ?After this, I?ve got something to present to the board.?

Immediately following a 4-1 vote that ousted Abee, with Haley the only vote against it, Kirby made a motion to not only invite David Rutherford back to McMinnville, but to employ him.

?I make a motion that we invite Mr. David Rutherford back for discussion and that we move forward with hiring him,? said Kirby.

After the motion was seconded by Wood, Haley once again asked why. To that Kirby stated that he believes Rutherford is the best candidate they had interviewed in the last year.

Kirby also said he had contacted legal council and before Rutherford could be brought back, Abee had to be removed.

Once again the motion was passed with a 4-1 vote with Haley the only vote against it. The vote sparked a flurry of speculation and anger.

?I guess this means I can go back through all the past applicants and pick any one of them to come in for an interview,? said Haley visibly upset by what appeared to be a well-planned strategic move by his fellow aldermen. ?I have two or three people whose names have been removed for the city administrator. If that no longer matters, I?ll contact them.?

The maneuver was so well planned that some at the meeting began to speculate if the Sunshine Law was broken in the attempt to construct it.

Mayor Royce Davenport is apparently one of the people who suspects an inappropriate amount of secrecy was involved. He handed out copies of the Sunshine Law to aldermen in a city meeting held Thursday.

Kirby, who openly admits to being the one who began talking to other elected officials in an effort to bring Rutherford back, denies breaking the Sunshine Law.

?No, the Sunshine Law was not broken,? said Kirby when asked the question later. ?I have personally talked to most board members individually. I told them I was interested in David Rutherford. I asked each one if they would consider bringing him back and talking to him and they said they would.?

Despite this claim, the Southern Standard has been made aware, by a reliable source, that at least three aldermen held a private discussion that led up to Rutherford being brought from the ashes.

Although Kirby denies breaking any laws, he did disclose one plan to the Standard that isn?t being kept under wraps.

?I want to hire him? said Kirby. ?My plan is to have Rutherford here in the next seven days and on the job in 30 days. That?s my goal. I think I have enough support to do that.?

Per the discussions with Rutherford, he would accept a one-year contract with a salary of $75,000 if the board would agree to establish a set of goals and objectives and give him six months to achieve them.

At the end of the six months, a review will determine if Rutherford has achieved his objectives and if elected officials want to renew the contract at the end of the year.

If Rutherford performs as expected, he would be given an increase to $80,000, what the last city administrator was paid. Subsequently, if he does not perform as expected, Rutherford will not be given the raise.

Two objects that are currently being discussed include:

? Doing a study and presenting the board with a new pay scale for all city employees, something that hasn?t been done in years.

? Putting together a budget that will allow the city to continue with the projects that are currently under way and give city employees their cost-of-living increase without raising taxes.

Despite Kirby?s discussions with Rutherford, his employment and the conditions of that employment must still be accepted by the board.

Davenport was asked Tuesday night to contact Rutherford for a return visit to McMinnville. Almost anticipating the visit, Rutherford arrived in McMinnville yesterday and will remain until Saturday. In that time he will have meetings with elected officials and department heads.

Leave a Comment