Closed-circuit video equipment goes unused – Sheriff says inmates have right to court appearance
After conferring with Sheriff Jackie Matheny at a recent Safety Committee meeting, County Executive John Pelham will not be purchasing an $875 maintenance contract for the closed-circuit video arraignment equipment installed last year at the jail and courthouse.
The system, which cost around $14,000, was the brainchild of former County Executive Kenneth Rogers, who received information from McMinnville Electric System CEO Rodney Boyd about a similar system used in Dalton, Ga. Rogers felt the system would offer a cost savings to the county, as well as improve security.
?We?re going to save on transportation costs,? Rogers said at the time. ?Security is of the utmost importance, and this will help with that since the prisoners won?t have to be transported into town.?
Discussion about obtaining the equipment began in April 2005. Rogers presented the idea to the Warren County Commission, which approved the funds as a line item in the 2005-2006 county budget.
The county took bids on the system in November of 2005 and IVCI, a company which specializes in this type of equipment, was awarded the bid. It was installed in March 2006, but, according to officials, has seen little use since.
Pelham received the invoice for the maintenance contract in his office recently, but after hearing that the equipment wasn?t being used, and conferring with director of accounts Linda Hillis, decided to check with Sheriff Matheny to see if there was any possibility the equipment might be used before declining the contract.
Matheny said the main problem is prisoners have to agree to use the video arraignment system.
?They have the right to go to court and stand in front of the judge,? Matheny pointed out. ?They found that out pretty quickly. We had one or two use it, but all of a sudden it went to zero. You can use the video arraignment if they agree to it. But you have to give them the option.?
And given the choice, according to Matheny, the majority of prisoners opt for the chance to leave the jail to attend court, which didn?t surprise some commissioners.
?Everybody wants out to get some fresh air,? quipped Safety Committee chairman David Grissom.
General Sessions Judge Larry Ross had asked Pelham if the video arraignment equipment could be removed from his courtroom.
?Judge Ross sent word up here to the office that he wanted the equipment pulled out of his courtroom,? Pelham said. ?He said he didn?t use it, it was in the way and he didn?t even want it. They want it removed.?
When contacted yesterday, Ross reported the equipment had already been taken down in his courtroom at his request and put in storage.
?It wasn?t being used and it wasn?t effective,? Ross said. ?I think their intentions were good, but it just didn?t pan out that way because of the law.?
Committee members agreed there was no reason to purchase the service contract.
?Why pay to maintain it if we?re not going to use it,? said Commissioner Les Trotman. ?That doesn?t make any sense.?
?It?s just sitting around collecting dust,? said Matheny.
