City acted in best interest of taxpayers
McMinnville city officials deserve praise for listening to both sides of the issue and making an informed decision to go with architect James Hailey instead of EG&G for phase II of the downtown revitalization plan.
That?s not to endorse Hailey or denounce EG&G. Outside of using tax dollars wisely, the Standard doesn?t care which company oversees downtown construction. But it?s the phase ?using tax dollars wisely? which quickly catches the eye when talking about EG&G.
By all accounts, EG&G did a fine job on phase I revitalization on Main Street. Downtown McMinnville, particularly Court Square, is an area in which the entire county can take pride.
However, the final $5.17 million pricetag has continued to be a sore spot for taxpayers who believe the job could have been done for less. When EG&G?s $4.2 million bid for phase II was released, city officials joined the chorus.
Several aldermen openly said they thought the bid was too high. That?s when the idea was presented to approach EG&G and discuss cost-saving measures.
However, EG&G president John Grossman was interested in no such conversation. After earning nearly three-quarters of a million dollars in fees from the first phase of downtown construction, Grossmann intended to keep his hand in the cookie jar. He said his $4.2 estimate was firm.
Alderman Bobby Kirby, who spearheaded the move to hire Hailey instead of EG&G, says he called Grossmann to discuss several items on his estimate. Kirby says his call was greeted with the warmth of frostbite.
According to Kirby, Grossmann said EG&G?s fees are not negotiable. The city of McMinnville could take it or leave it.
Thankfully for city taxpayers, aldermen decided to leave it.
One glaring aspect of the EG&G phase I bill was that McMinnville taxpayers were charged twice for engineering work EG&G did not perform. EG&G was adding its own engineering charges on top of engineering work done by other companies which, if accurate, seems almost fraudulent.
When EG&G was asked to explain the charges, to clear up what could have been a simple misunderstanding, Grossmann slammed the door. Kirby and Vice Mayor Donald Hillis both said they thought the prospect of Grossmann ever coming to McMinnville to talk with city officials was bleak.
In contrast, Hailey was more than happy to come to McMinnville and submit to what amounted to a two-hour interrogation from city officials. That at least gives the appearance of openness and honesty.
EG&G gives quite another appearance and ample reasons for suspicion. Since Grossmann was unwilling to clear up those suspicions, they still linger.
While EG&G did a noteworthy job on phase I, city officials were wise to keep their options open. They were able to question Hailey and consider EG&G?s lack of cooperation. In the end, it appears they made a responsible move concerning the use of city tax dollars.
