Skip to content

Don?t let spam drive you mad: Blockers can be effective at stopping unwanted mail

It?s been more than two years since Congress passed the Can-Spam Act, and despite prosecutions and several high-profile civil settlements under that landmark legislation, unwanted ? and often fraudulent ? solicitations still make up most of the e-mail traffic on the Internet.

To keep these messages from flooding their ?In? boxes, many consumers rely on spam blockers supplied by such large Internet service providers (ISPs) as AOL, MSN and EarthLink.

These can be effective: AOL?s blocker, for example, is so aggressive that for periods sometimes lasting days it has inadvertently stopped mail from legitimate sources. Spamblockers are also in Microsoft Outlook and other e-mail programs. Still, it may not be enough.

If spam remains excessive even with these blockers switched on (some ISPs and operating systems do so automatically, others require activation), you might consider adding antispam software. It needn?t cost much. In fact, the best performer we tested was free.

BLOCKERS: ADD-ONS AND UPGRADES

In tests measuring how well a product correctly identified e-mail that wasn?t spam, Trend Micro Anti-Spam Pilot was nearly flawless, spotting the difference more than 95 percent of the time. (The poor performers in our tests did no better than 80 percent.)

Not only is Anti-Spam Pilot free to download (www.trendmicro.com), there?s no annual fee.

Like all add-on software we tested, Trend Micro is compatible with Windows XP, but not with Mac OS 9 or OS X. If you have a Mac, and it uses an older version of the Apple Mail program, consider upgrading to Apple OS 10.4.6 Mail ($130; no annual fee). An excellent product overall, it includes a ?learning? feature that blocks spam by identifying patterns in your e-mail.

Although Microsoft Outlook 2003 ($100; no annual fee) doesn’t have Apple Mail’s capacity to learn, it was excellent at identifying spam while not confusing good mail with bad.

If your PC is equipped with an e-mail program other than Outlook or Outlook Express and you want add-on protection, consider Allume Systems SpamCatcher ($30; $10 annual fee).

The most feature rich of our top-performing add-ons ? it?s one of the few to check messages against a ?live? online database of reported spam messages ? SpamCatcher works with POP3 e-mail programs, including Eudora. But while SpamCatcher learns from you which messages are spam and which are not, be careful how you teach it: In our tests, the software?s performance decreased slightly after training.

A MULTILAYER

DEFENSE

Other programs can help protect you from viruses (malicious programs that infect computers and use them to propagate) and spyware (it surreptitiously tracks your movements online and reports them to marketers). Among the best antivirus software for PCs we tested was BitDefender Standard (it?s available for $30 by download only at bitdefender.com; $20 annual fee), Zone Labs ZoneAlarm Antivirus ($30; $20 annual fee) and Kaspersky Labs Anti-Virus Personal ($50; $35 annual fee). Norton Antivirus for Macintosh ($50; $15 annual fee) is also an excellent program.

For top-notch PC protection against spyware, consider Webroot Spy Sweeper 4.5 ($25; $20 annual fee) and PC Tools Spyware Doctor 3.8 ($30; $20 annual fee). We recommend you use two antispyware programs to provide extra security, but enable the real-time protection of only one at a time.

A free package, Spybot Search and Destroy 1.4 is very good and available by download from spybot.info. You should obtain antispyware programs only from the official sites ? such as webroot.com and pctools.com ? because similar software offered at other sites may actually be spyware.

Security suites combining antispam, antivirus and antispyware programs are simple to manage and generally cost less than the sum of individual packages. But of the 10 suites we tested, only Zone Labs Zone Alarm Internet Security Suite ($70) provided very good or better protection against all three threats.

Visit the Consumer Reports Web site at www.consumerreports.org.

Leave a Comment