Skip to content

Davis butts heads with ?sign Nazis?: New sign ordinance creates controversy

Davis butts heads with ?sign Nazis?: New sign ordinance creates controversy

If a new city ordinance is passed, signs won?t be able to exceed more than one-third the total area of store windows.
Saying McMinnville sign code enforcement officials will become nothing more than ?sign Nazis? if the city continues its restrictive trend, local sign-maker Steve Davis fought city hall this week, calling parts of the decision making body a cloak and dagger commission.

?We have an Appropriateness Commission that acts as a bunch of tastemakers,? Davis said as he appeared before the McMinnville Regional Planning Commission to contest various areas of the city?s proposed sign code. ?What?s that other than harassment??

Davis, of Davis Signs, questioned why members of the Appropriateness Commission, which is an arm of the downtown Historical District Commission which decides what is allowable in the way of advertising and signs in the newly revitalized area, do not sign the forms when requests for signs are turned down.

Davis suggested the commission acts as a shadow commission without accountability, something which irritated Scott Wilson, who is a member of both the Planning Commission and the Historical Commission.

?Now you?re just making me mad,? Wilson said of Davis? tirade, noting the meetings of the historical board are open to the public and that the commission is not trying to legislate taste.

Questions about sign policies arose as the Regional Planning Commission was discussing changes in the sign law, which includes a code which would control signage in store fronts for any sign within three feet of the window.

?It would be a nightmare to regulate window signs,? Davis said. ?The next thing will be people going around with yardsticks, measuring the distance from window to sign. What we?ll have is a bunch of sign Nazis.?

The present plan is to regulate store window signs so they do not exceed one-third of the total space of the window. The plan also counts window signs as one of the three signs allowed for each business. City planner Jack Qualls pointed out some businesses are avoiding regulation by using window signage, therefore lending a need for a code to cover such advertising.

A vote of the finalized plan will be held later and must be ratified by the entire McMinnville Board of Mayor and Aldermen before becoming city code.

Wilson defended the planned change in code, saying it would help slow urban blight whereby the skyline would be cluttered with signs if they were no rules to restrict signage.

Commission member Jerry Williamson admitted there needs to be a happy medium met between beauty and advertising.

?There have been merchants downtown wanting to get away so there must be something we are doing wrong,? Williamson said. ?We need to look at that.?

Davis said in downtown?s heyday, back in the 1950s and even before, signs like Fraley?s were huge and were part of the identity of downtown.

?If you tried to get a permit for a sign like that nowadays, there?d be no way,? Davis said.

Leave a Comment