Sen. Cooper real target, attorneys say: Prosecutors claim he used political influence to obtain $1.7 million loan
|
Assistant U.S. Attorney Gary Humble said in an opening statement that the appraisal helped the buyers of Cooper?s lumber mill get a $1.7 million bank loan and later an equipment loan of more than $400,000 from the state.
Humble said the indicted appraiser, James B. Passons of McMinnville, had a ?limited role? in a scheme where Cooper asked Lt. Gov. John Wilder and Bill Baxter, then the Tennessee commissioner for economic development, for help getting the loans.
Neither Cooper, Wilder nor Baxter, now a Tennessee Valley Authority board member, are charged. Cooper and Wilder are Democrats. Baxter is a Republican.
Defense attorney Michael Galligan said Passons did not intend to defraud anybody when he appraised the value of Cooper?s Warren County property at $1.56 million and showed it included a nonexistent rail spur.
Galligan told jurors that Passons believed assurances about the rail spur by his longtime friend Cooper that, ?It’s a sure thing. The rail spur will be there. This appraisal won?t be used until the rail spur is there.?
Humble said Passons, charged with bank fraud, mail fraud and conspiracy to commit bank and mail fraud, ?wrote an appraisal that contained false representations.?
Defense attorneys have also maintained out of court that Cooper is the real target of the government?s case.
Galligan said he would begin presenting the defense side this afternoon.
The trial started one day after the other two co-defendants pleaded guilty. A Huntsville, Ala., couple, Anthony C. Auyer and Teresa R. Auyer, admitted to charges of fraud, money laundering and conspiracy.
Although it doesn’t name Cooper, the 2005 indictment against Passons and the Auyers lists him as an unindicted co-conspirator as the mill?s property owner. His attorney, Jerry Summers, has said prosecutors have identified Cooper as a ?potential target? in the ongoing investigation. Cooper has said he did not do anything wrong.
The indictment accuses Passons of preparing an inflated appraisal for the mill property in 1998. Cooper then sold the property to Auyer?s company, with a commitment from the state Department of Economic and Community Development that a grant would be issued to Auyer to build the rail spur, records show.
State officials said the spur was never built.
The indictment says the unindicted co-conspirator ?used his political contacts, connections and influence? to help Anthony Auyer obtain a $1.77 million federally insured loan from BankTennessee, where Wilder is a board member.
?Cooper calls up his friend, Lieutenant Governor John Wilder on the Bank of Tennessee board of directors,? Humble told the panel of eight women and five men jurors. ?He calls up Mr. Wilder and says ?I need your help.? Wilder calls in Wayne Rodgers, a loan officer, and says, ?Help him.??
When the bank board refused to approve the loan, ?Wilder gets personally involved? and the Auyers in November 1999 got a bank loan guaranteed by the government, Humble said.
Humble said Cooper got $800,000 of the money to pay another loan, the bank kept $500,000 as security and the Auyers received the remaining amount for working capital and equipment in the lumber mill, which failed.
Wilder initially said he spoke with Cooper about the loan but later said he never spoke to Cooper about it.
BankTennessee at Collierville senior vice president Chris Zuercher said a subsequent appraisal by Passons in bank records showed the property without the spur valued at $185,000.
The indictment also contends the Auyers fraudulently obtained equipment loans totaling about $409,000 from the state in 2000, also using inflated values of land the Auyers owned in Alabama. Passons was not involved in those appraisals.
Baxter has said Cooper called him about a 1998 economic development grant intended to build a railroad spur but never mentioned it would benefit him financially by connecting the senator?s property to a rail line.
Humble said the state initially turned down the loan application but then Baxter said: ?I got a call from Jerry Cooper. That loan gets made.?
Philip Trauernicht, the Department of Economic and Community Development?s director of program management, testified he had some concerns about the loan but he ?absolutely? considered Baxter?s support to be an order to help get it passed.

