Skip to content

Champions drop $1.5M lawsuit against county: Sheriff?s department arrested entire family

Champions drop $1.5M lawsuit against county: Sheriff?s department arrested entire family

HAL CHAMPION
A $1.5 million lawsuit filed by family members who said they were mistreated by deputies has been dropped against Warren County, Sheriff Jackie Matheny and former deputy Stewart Colwell.

?I think the plaintiffs realized after they started taking depositions that there was another side to the story,? said County Attorney Larry Stanley, of the permanent dismissal of the lawsuit.

The suit, filed by Hal and Janice Champion in federal court last summer, asked for $500,000 in compensatory damages and $1 million in punitive damages against former sheriff?s deputy Stuart Colwell, Sheriff Jackie Matheny, in his role as sheriff, and the county of Warren.

The suit came after an incident June 6, 2004 in which Lance Champion, son of the plaintiffs, stopped deputy Stan Hillis near Three Star Mall and accused the lawman of speeding. An exchange between the two transpired, leading to Champion?s arrest. It was minutes later Janice Champion and son Stephen, 17, arrived to check on Lance. At that point there was allegedly an exchange between Stephen and deputy Colwell, during which the teen slapped the lawman?s hand and was arrested. Mrs. Champion was arrested minutes later.

Mr. Champion, who had a confrontation with officers when he arrived to check on his family, was subdued with a taser gun by Colwell as his wife and son watched from nearby patrol cars. The arrests of Mr. and Mrs. Champion were the basis of the lawsuit.

The suit was brought after grand jurors refused to indict the Champions after hearing the evidence against them. The juvenile court did convict Stephen Champion for assault on an officer. His case is still under appeal.

The suit was dropped with an agreement the defense would pay $25,000 in attorneys fees. However, Stanley said that is in no way any admission of guilt on the part of any of the defendants.

Stuart Colwell, now an officer in Manchester, said he is relieved the lawsuit is over given the fact it has hung over his head for two years.

?I?ve had five commendations for service and been named officer of the year there, but I?ll always be remembered for the Champion family,? Colwell said, in thanking those who supported him during the ordeal. ?I want to thank the sheriff because he supported us when it may not have been the good political thing to do. He did the right thing.?

Colwell added attorneys have been quick to question how things were handled on the side of the road that night.

?We have to react and make a decision in the field in a matter of seconds while attorneys have got years to make a decision,? Colwell added.

Sheriff Jackie Matheny said he wishes the best for the Champions despite the lawsuit.

?It?s unfortunate any of this happened,? said Matheny. ?Hopefully we can all now put this behind us.?

The incident which led to the entire matter, Lance Champion questioning an officer about speeding, was explained by the college student during his deposition in preparation for the case.

?My intention was not to pull over and criticize his conduct. My intentions were to speak with the officer and hopefully instill something positive into him,? Lance Champion said during depositions. ?After the fact, I do see that it was very naive. I didn?t claim to have infinite wisdom, obviously, and I didn?t want to straighten him out. But I will agree I have no idea what came over me to make me want to do that.?

Lance Champion also said he wishes he had not used the cellphone, left in his pocket while he was in the back of the patrol car, to call his parents.

?I was scared to death because I didn?t believe the officer had probable cause or any cause to arrest me, and so I thought he was crazy,? Champion said. ?I wish very much I hadn?t made that call, but my only experience with law enforcement was (what I?d seen) in the movies. I was picturing in my mind I was going to be taken out back somewhere and beaten.?

Leave a Comment