Skip to content

Preacher?s wife confessurdes to mer: Why did she do it? Community struggles to find answers

Preacher?s wife confessurdes to mer: Why did she do it? Community struggles to find answers

Former Central Church of Christ youth minister Matt Winkler, front left, is shown in this group photo during a Central church gathering. His wife, Mary Winkler, is pictured in the middle of the second row wearing blue suspenders. She has confessed to his
Why did Mary Winkler gun down her husband of 10 years in their family home and then flee to a Gulf Coast resort town with their three children?

The question of ?why? has spread through the Warren County community in the wake of the stunning murder of former Central Church of Christ youth minister Matt Winkler.

Winkler?s body was found by church members Wednesday night at his parsonage, located about two miles from the church he ministered, Fourth Street Church of Christ in Selmer, a place the family had called home for just over a year. The town is located about 80 miles east of Memphis in McNairy County, which is best known as being the home of Buford Pusser of ?Walking Tall? fame.

While saying they know why she shot her husband, TBI officials are not revealing the motive. When specifically asked by the Standard about a possible motive yesterday, TBI spokeswoman Jennifer Johnson said the agency is not releasing that information.

However, agents have said they do not believe it was infidelity. They have not said if Mrs. Winkler cited any alleged abuse as a reason for the murder.

The couple?s three children, ages 1, 6, and 8, are in the custody of their paternal grandparents after a custody hearing was held in Alabama prior to Mrs. Winkler being brought back to McNairy County where she remains held without bond charged with first-degree murder.

She was found in Orange Beach, Ala., on Thursday night when lawmen stopped her Toyota van and discovered the children were wanted in an Amber Alert put out after the discovery of Mr. Winkler?s body. Lawmen in the resort town, where Mrs. Winkler had reportedly rented a condo, said the children appeared to be in good health and that the family was headed to a restaurant when they were approached by police.

It was during subsequent questioning, Mrs. Winkler confessed. Lawmen have said they do not believe the children witnessed the murder of their father ? although they were at home at the time.

?She confessed to planning the murder of her husband ? shooting him on March 22,? reads the affidavit filed for the arrest warrant.

The confession to cold-blooded murder in the seemingly happy Christian family has floored those who knew them during their nearly three-year ministry in McMinnville.

?If you had told me this, I would have said prove it to me,? said Charles Bogle, an elder at Central. ?This is just hard to believe.?

Bogle, who is also McMinnville Postmaster, said Mrs. Winkler worked at the post office annex at Super D. Along with being a postal employee, Mrs. Winkler was also active in Warren County, even outside her church work.

?She was very active in our club,? said Junior Auxiliary member Pam Cantrell who was a fellow member of the local club with Mrs. Winkler. ?If we had an event, she was there.?

Cantrell said home life is sometimes discussed among club members. However, she said she heard nothing out of the ordinary from Mrs. Winkler.

?She was so meek and quiet,? Cantrell said, noting pictures she has seen since Mrs. Winkler?s arrest do not look like her old self. ?Sometimes folks would talk about their spouses, but she never mentioned any trouble. I would never have thought this.?

Those who knew her well say they are stunned by her murder confession. Tammy Young, of Tammy?s Little Tikes, said Mary had been a good friend.

?I loved her,? Young said. ?I kept her child. She was just a very sweet girl. She seemed happy with Matt. I believe they were both striving to do what was right in the Lord. I was devastated when I heard it happened. I?m still devastated. I loved them both. ?

As to what motive Mrs. Winkler may have had, Young said she has no idea.

?There must have been something nobody knew about,? Young said. ?I never saw anything. Matthew was a sweet man.?

Young said Winkler seemed to cater to her husband and appeared to be a conscientious wife.

?No matter what she was doing, she would drop it to do whatever he needed done,? Young said. ?She supported Matthew in everything he did.?

Leave a Comment