Skip to content

Indoor smoking bans encouraged as tobacco influence wanes

NASHVILLE — Efforts to restrict smoking in public places are gaining momentum as Tennessee’s status as a tobacco state wanes.

But even supporters of indoor smoking bans don’t anticipate any rapid changes.

Gov. Phil Bredesen, who describes himself as an “avid nonsmoker,” has said he doesn’t expect any new laws on the matter this session, but smoking bans have become more plausible with the state’s changing agricultural landscape, he said.

“It has been impossible in Tennessee because we had been a tobacco state for years and years,” Bredesen said before last week’s trip to Iraq and Afghanistan. “We’re kind of coming out of that era now.”

Tennessee’s tobacco crop was about 65 million pounds in 2004 — about half of what it was a decade earlier.

Lower demand from cigarette companies and increased foreign competition have contributed to the decline, and many growers in Tennessee are using a federal buyout program to get out of the business.

Several bills proposing indoor smoking bans in public places are scheduled to be debated in legislative committees this week.

A Senate committee on local government has signaled that it may give some of the bills serious consideration, while bills assigned to the House Agriculture Committee appear to face more stiff opposition.

House Majority Leader Kim McMillan has defended the practice of sending anti-smoking bills to the agriculture committee, even though that has meant their certain death in the past.

“We really try, when we assign bills, to go through the process of looking at where similar bills have gone in the past, so we can be consistent,” said the Clarksville Democrat.

But doesn’t their assignment to the agriculture committee guarantee they will fail?

“No,” McMillan answered. “I think it consistently guarantees that we’re being consistent.”

In the Senate State and Local Government Committee last week, Sen. Jeff Miller said recent travels to Florida and New York have changed his mind about banning cigarette smoking in restaurants.

“Smoke-free Tennessee is going to happen. I don’t know when, but it’s going to happen,” said Miller, a Cleveland Republican who has announced he won’t run for re-election in the fall.

More than a dozen states and many more cities and counties across the country — including New York, Chicago and Dallas — have banned smoking in restaurants and bars.

“I’m going to vote for every smoke-free bill that I get a chance to vote for, and that’s a complete change from where I had been,” Miller said.

Miller previously sponsored bills that would ban smoking inside all public buildings, but said he now realizes that a more narrow approach is needed to get the smoking ban going.

That’s not welcome news to the Tennessee Restaurant Association, which feels it is unfairly being singled out.

“Why do we pick out restaurants for this kind of treatment?” asked restaurant lobbyist Dan Haskell. “Why not grocery stores, hardware stores or lawyers offices?”

Miller was unsympathetic to Haskell’s complaints.

“Let’s be a leader for once, and not say that we’re picking on you and say, ‘Hey, we’re going to embrace this,'” he said. “Because we know it’s coming.”

Meanwhile in the House, Rep. Paul Stanley tried to play down the potential effects of his bill to give towns and cities the power to vote on whether to ban smoking in restaurants.

“Let me be honest with you: I do not believe that a lot of cities and towns in this state really want to ban smoking,” said Stanley, R-Germantown. “It is politically volatile.”

But those towns that do want to — like Germantown — should be able to “be responsive to their particular constituency,” he said.

Rep. Frank Niceley, a member of the agriculture committee, said he sides with restaurant owners in the debate.

“I’m for their freedom to decide how to run their restaurants,” said Niceley, R-Strawberry Plains.

Leave a Comment