No Child Left Behind drives up tutoring cost
Officials can’t yet say if student test scores have changed since 2002.
Many teachers who once staffed Hamilton County’s in-house tutoring?classes for $15 an hour now do the work for private companies at $25 an hour.
“When a teacher is sought by the school system to work in an in-house enrichment program after hours for $15 or a private tutoring program for $25, the choice is easy,” said Lucile Phillips, who heads the county’s federal programs office.
The government-funded tutoring?is free to parents but the extra help costs two to three times more than before the federal changes privatized tutoring, Hamilton County school officials told the Chattanooga Times Free Press.
Federally funded tutoring programs provided by Hamilton County Schools before the law cost about $500 a student, Phillips said.
No Child Left Behind, signed into law in January 2002, requires that private tutoring be offered at schools with low test scores and high numbers of low-income students. That drove up the cost of Hamilton County’s tutoring to $1,300 a student, Phillips said.
Private companies are “using the same teachers I was using,” she said.
So far, neither the state nor federal government has evaluated the tutoring?services. A planned assessment in Tennessee was due last month but state officials say it will not be complete until later in the spring.
Rachel Woods, spokeswoman for the Tennessee Department of Education, said the University of Memphis has a contract to analyze the test results of each student in the private tutoring programs. Evaluators with the University of Memphis declined comment and referred questions to state officials.
Last month, officials from the U.S. Government Accountability Office visited Hamilton County as one of four school districts being analyzed to prepare an upcoming report to Congress.
Marnie Shaul, director of education, work force and income security issues at the GAO, said the visits in Chattanooga; Chicago; Woodburn, Ore.; and Newark, N.J., would supplement the report.
GAO analysts also mailed surveys to 258 school districts to learn how the private tutoring requirement of the No Child Left Behind Act is working and is being monitored, Shaul said.
“We are looking at comparison of costs,” she said. “And one of the things we’re asking states is how they are evaluating the program. Is student performance improving?”
Shaul declined to discuss any findings. The report to Congress will be released in August.
Cheri Dedmon, retired principal of East Ridge High School, now runs the Newton Learning program, a division of Edison Schools, in four Hamilton County schools, including East Lake Academy. She said private tutoring?can offer what schools often can’t.
“In our case, the company spent $12 million in research, curriculum and materials before it even started the teaching. And when we begin a program, the teachers get boxes of hands-on materials, the kinds of things affluent parents have always had for their children, but some of these kids may never have had,” she said.
Dedmon also manages Newton tutoring?programs in four Birmingham, Ala., schools; five Charleston, S.C., schools; two Louisiana schools; and two Arkansas schools, as well as a home tutoring?program for about 400 students in Kentucky.
In Hamilton County, about 800 of almost 4,000 eligible students are signed up for tutoring, Phillips said.
“If every child who signs up for supplemental educational services attends, the cost would exceed $1 million,” she said. ??
Last year, based on student attendance, Hamilton County paid private tutoring companies $338,033. Phillips said she expects the cost “to be close to double that this year.”
“The private companies are coming out great,” Phillips said.
Across the state, the Davidson County, Hamilton County, Hardeman County, Knox County and Memphis city school districts paid a total of $3.4 million for the private tutoring?of 2,991 students, an average cost of about $1,146 per student, said Woods, a Department of Education spokeswoman.
Those districts have 23,117 students eligible for the special help.
East Lake Academy teachers Tamara Parks works extra hours at the school as a Newton tutor.
“We’re helping the kids develop test-taking skills and skills needed in the classroom,” Parks said.
——
Information from: Chattanooga Times Free Press, http://www.timesfreepress.com
