Skip to content

TVA says emissions lowest in history

KNOXVILLE, Tenn. Copyright 2006 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. — The Tennessee Valley Authority said Wednesday that smokestack pollution from its 11 coal-fired power plants has reached historically low levels.

“At TVA, our actions speak louder than words,” TVA Chairman Bill Baxter said in a statement clearly aimed at a lawsuit by North Carolina’s attorney general challenging the country’s largest public utility to make further reductions.

“Data from the Environmental Protection Agency show the air is cleaner now than it has been at any time in our lives,” Baxter said, pledging that “TVA will continue leading the industry in supplying reliable power while improving regional air quality.”

Attorney General Roy Cooper said in filing the lawsuit Jan. 30 that TVA pollution wafting on prevailing west-to-east winds across the Smoky Mountains “is making North Carolinians sick, damaging our economy and harming our environment.”

“We’re glad that North Carolina’s efforts to clean the air are causing TVA to realize the importance of reducing harmful emissions, and we hope that TVA will agree to meet with us to work out a binding agreement for TVA to match North Carolina’s reductions in years to come,” Cooper spokeswoman Noelle Talley said Wednesday

“Both sides are partially right,” said Stephen Smith, director of the Knoxville-based environmental group Southern Alliance for Clean Energy. “TVA has made progress, but what they were doing (before) was horrible, and it needs to be put in that context.”

In some ways the federal utility’s voluntary program is ahead of North Carolina’s new pollution mandates on investor-owned utilities, he said.

“But the question is, are they where they need to be to be protecting public health and the environment. And the answer is clearly, no. Neither North Carolina nor TVA has reached those areas that we need to be at,” Smith said.

TVA, which gets 62 percent of its electricity from a fleet of coal-fired power plants in Alabama, Kentucky and Tennessee, has reduced sulfur dioxide emissions from a peak of 2.2 million tons a year in 1977 to 460,000 tons in 2005 — an 80 percent drop in a pollutant that causes acid rain and regional haze, particularly in the Great Smoky Mountains National Park.

However, that’s still 30,000 tons more than TVA is allowed under the Clean Air Act, forcing the utility to use pollution credits earned from early installation of smokestack scrubbers to stay within air quality limits. TVA has yet to go to the option of buying credits from other utilities to meet the limits.

TVA installed its first pollution-capturing scrubber in 1977 and now has six in operation. It plans to add four more by 2010 — costing $1.5 billion. But that still will leave most of its 59 individual boilers without scrubber technology.

Baxter noted North Carolina, which has passed a “clean smokestacks” act setting deadlines for North Carolina utilities to curb these pollutants, didn’t get its first scrubber until 2005.

Although TVA’s fossil plants range from nearly 30 to more than 50 years old, TVA was able to boost their generation by 3.5 percent last year to 98.6 million megawatt-hours, enough to supply more than 6.5 million consumers, while cutting sulfur dioxide emissions 6.6 percent.

Meanwhile, TVA also has significantly cut nitrogen oxide emissions, which form ozone in the summer that can make breathing difficult for the young and elderly. Annual releases are down from a peak of 529,800 tons in 1995 to 191,000 tons in 2005.

During the critical summer “ozone season,” TVA nitrogen oxide pollution has dropped 80 percent through the operation of 20 catalytic reduction systems costing $1.3 billion.

TVA, a self-financing federal agency that provides electricity to 8.5 million people in Tennessee, Georgia, North Carolina, Virginia, Kentucky, Alabama and Mississippi, has spent $5.7 billion on pollution controls at its coal-fired plants since 1977.

However, TVA has yet to substantially trim such related pollutants as mercury and carbon dioxide.

“I would say TVA deserves credit for the steps they have taken,” Smith said. “But there are additional steps that need to be taken and it is unclear exactly how TVA is going to make those steps going forward.”

——

TVA: http://www.tva.gov

Leave a Comment