The holy war over abortion
Iraq can’t make democracy work, goes a common argument in Washington, because its political culture is fragmented by religious, tribal and ethnic loyalties. Those loyalties breed a fundamentalist mind-set that resists compromise, an essential part of any functioning democratic system.
But on the issue of abortion, American politics is often plagued by the same self-righteous rigidity that is damaging democracy in Baghdad. Hard-line pro-life and pro-choice factions sound like Sunnis and Shiites — firmly convinced of their own God-given mission.
Two out of three voters tell CNN that they accept the fair-minded framework laid out in a series of Supreme Court decisions: abortion should be legal, but so should reasonable restrictions that don’t impose an “undue burden” on pregnant women.
This consensus against extremism is clear. In a Pew Research Center survey, only 30 percent said abortion should be “generally available” and only 16 percent favored an outright ban. CBS found 27 percent supporting abortion “in all cases” while 22 percent said it should be legal only to “save a woman’s life” or not at all.
These reasonable views are anathema to the holy warriors. Granted, both sides believe they are fighting for basic principles, but that’s not the whole story. Fanaticism also feeds their institutional interests. Only by demanding purity can they keep emotions stirred up, cameras turned on and checks flowing in.
On the pro-choice side, militants have dominated the Democratic Party and its platform for many years, a situation that has driven a steady stream of conservative Christians out of party ranks. Al Gore barely won the Catholic vote in 2000 and four years later John Kerry, a practicing Catholic, actually lost his fellow religionists to a Methodist.
In Ohio alone, Bush captured the Catholic vote by a margin of 156,000, while winning the state by 136,000. If Kerry had won the Catholic vote in Ohio he’d be president today.
But the Democrats don’t seem to have learned much since then. Abortion rights advocates helped discourage several pro-life officeholders from seeking the Democratic Senate nomination in Rhode Island. In Pennsylvania, they’re furious with the party’s likely Senate nominee, Robert P. Casey Jr., for his opposition to abortion.
Given this toxic climate, it was heartening to see 55 Catholic Democrats in the House try recently to apply a measure of decontamination. They issued a “statement of principles” that recognized “the church’s role in providing moral leadership” while insisting that “primacy of conscience” should leave room for dissent from church teachings.
They also asserted that other issues should be equally important to the church and its followers, from poverty and health care to education and war. “This is about the whole notion that the Catholic purpose is not defined by one issue,” Rep. Rosa DeLauro, D-Conn., told the Religious News Service.
In reply, church elders expressed support for social justice, but continued to insist that since “abortion is a grave violation of the most fundamental human right,” it takes precedence over every other issue.
But it shouldn’t. The abortion issue distorts our entire political and legal process. Just look how it infected the debate over Justices John Roberts and Samuel Alito.
That’s why those 55 Catholics were right to look for a common ground that reconciles moral principles with a decent respect for dissenting views. That decent respect is badly lacking in Iraq, and on the abortion issue, it’s badly lacking in America as well.
Steve and Cokie Roberts can be contacted by e-mail at [email protected].
