Skip to content

Schools reach agreement on Bible reading by students

KNOXVILLE, Tenn. Copyright 2006 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. — Attorneys for Knoxville schools and the parents of a fifth-grader who claims he was told he could not hold a Bible study during recess have reached an agreement that spells out the rights of students to read religious texts at school.

But the federal lawsuit brought by the parents remains unresolved, as does a libel suit brought against the parents by the school’s principal.

Fifth-grader Luke Whitson and his parents Samuel and Tina Whitson claim Luke was told by Cathy Summa, principal of Karns Elementary School, that he could not hold a Bible study during recess. Summa denies that the incident ever took place.

The agreement was reached Tuesday after both sides were dressed down by U.S. District Court Judge Thomas Phillips for not yet reaching a settlement and dragging out a case that could be costly to taxpayers.

“Counsel, I’m just really amazed. Something that apparently started as a misunderstanding has escalated into a lawsuit in federal court,” Phillips said.

Phillips ordered the sides to hold a closed meeting that resulted in the agreement that Knoxville schools have not and will not have a policy or practice of banning students from reading religious texts at recess.

“We’re hopeful that maybe this will be the first step to reach a resolution,” said Nathan Kellum, one of the Whitsons’ attorneys and senior litigation counsel for the Alliance Defense Fund, an Arizona-based Christian legal group.

But the lawsuits still stand, although the two parties agreed to report back to the judge April 6.

Summa’s suit seeks $3 million in damages for what she claims were false statements about her given to media outlets by the Whitsons when the dispute began

The Whitsons have filed a motion to dismiss that suit, but a hearing has not been scheduled.

——

Information from: The Knoxville News Sentinel, http://www.knoxnews.com

Leave a Comment