Former school boards chief disputes audit on payments
A state comptroller’s audit found that Tollett misled the association, which gets tax dollars from school systems as membership dues, by concocting a scheme that allowed him to collect a state pension while continuing to function as the association director by working under contract through an affiliated nonprofit organization.
“Mistakes have been made,” Bob Rochelle, interim administrator of the Tennessee Risk Management Trust and a former state senator, told the Joint Education Committee. “Those mistakes have been acknowledged, concrete steps have been taken to ensure that past problems will not be repeated and for the future success of the (trust).”
Senate Education Chairwoman Jamie Woodson challenged Rochelle about a potential conflict of interest because the former senator had previously served as a lawyer for Tollett and the trust.
Rochelle responded that he has obtained a written release from his former client and that his new role does not conflict with his previous work for the trust.
In a letter to legislators, Tollett disputed the results of the audit that questioned some $400,000 in retirement benefits he received, saying it caused “great damage to the reputation and influence of TSBA” and the trust he administered until Jan. 31.
Tollett’s attorney Gregory H. Oakley wrote in a separate letter that the audit contains “inaccurate and incomplete or misleading information.”
Comptrollers officials told the committee that they stand by their report.
The audit also found that James Evans, president of Next Generation Underwriters, had collected $551,694 in unauthorized fees, commissions and interest over the past two years as program manager at the trust. Evans has said the accusations were unfounded.
Woodson said she is concerned about Rochelle’s previous role, and that another lawyer, Keith Drennon, advises both the trust and Evans.
“Could this be a situation where we have too many people wearing too many hats?” asked Woodson, R-Knoxville.
The state sought repayment from Tollett of $276,856 in retirement benefits he received over seven years beginning in 1994. The association board later voted to repay the state.
Tollett was also to receive 15 percent of the salary amount put into an annuity each year. The audit said payments into the annuity fund totaled $120,000 over a 10-year period ending Dec. 31, 2003, and violated state retirement rules.
Meanwhile, TSBA attorney Dan Elrod has said he is preparing to file a lawsuit seeking reimbursement to the association of funds improperly paid to Tollett.
Elrod was also critical of Evans’ arrangement with trust, echoing committee members’ concerns about conflicts of interest.
“Mr. Evans’ company secures the reinsurance for this trust, and under the agreement he gets to keep all the commission from that,” Elrod told the committee Monday. “Well, he has a direct financial incentive not to buy the most cost-effective reinsurance for the trust, but in fact to buy the reinsurance that pays him the highest commission.”
Elrod said Evans received a 10-year contract paying $4 million per year without having to go through a competitive bid process.
“And that’s public money without any independent advice,” Elrod said.
Evans was in attendance at the hearing, but was not called on to speak.
“We’ve got to let this run through, and we’ll address it all later,” he told reporters afterward.
