River Park appeals jury?s $7.2M lawsuit award
Suggesting sympathy may have played a role in the jury?s decision to award $7.2 million to the family of Jewell Wayne Barkes, attorneys for River Park Hospital have asked the court for a new trial.
?None of the heath care providers failed to comply with standard of care,? the appellant wrote in filing the motion for new trial. ?The standard of care was appropriate and did not cause Mr. Barkes? death.?
The motion was filed Wednesday in Circuit Court civil division two months after a jury, following a lengthy trial, found River Park liable for the death of Barkes who had left the emergency room about half an hour prior to having a fatal heart attack.
He complained of arm pain during the visit, something the plaintiffs said health care providers should have taken as a possible indication of a cardiac problem given his medical history. He was diagnosed with overuse syndrome on his arm and sent home, where he suffered the heart attack.
The jury awarded the maximum amount applicable, with the award becoming the largest civil judgment in Warren County history. The former owner of River Park, HCA, will be liable for payment of any suit although Capella Healthcare has since purchased the local hospital.
The defense for River Park believes there were errors in the trial which warrant them either a reversal of verdict, a new trial, or a reduction in the amount of award to the victim?s family.
Specifically, River Park is asking Judge Bart Stanley to act as 13th Juror and put aside the judgment. The hospital bases its request on several factors ? first and foremost saying there was not sufficient evidence to find the hospital liable. The defense also says the court allowed prejudicial evidence and statements before the jury which tended to inflame opinion against the hospital.
?Counsel, during opening arguments, said ?The hospital is liable if Mr. Barkes died of a heart attack,?? the motion points out, saying the statement was inappropriate and prejudicial to the case.
?Counsel said ?The hospital did not live up to its responsibilities after Mr. Barkes? death,?? the motion reads, saying such a comment was also prejudicial and should not have been heard by the jury.
Along with prejudicial evidence, the defense maintains the verdict may have been driven by sympathy for the family given the verdict despite what the defense terms as a lack of evidence.
In addition to the finding of fault, the defense is questioning the large award.
?The amount exceeds the reasonable range,? the motion reads.
A response from the family?s attorneys will be forthcoming the coming months. A hearing will then be scheduled before Judge Stanley, following which the judge will rule on the motion for new trial. Should he deny the motion, River Park may then appeal the case to the Tennessee Court of Appeals.
