Double standard?Teachers sex cases different, DA says
|
Comparisons between Pamela Rogers and a male Van Buren County teacher accused of having a sexual affair with a female student are incorrect, according to District Attorney General Dale Potter, who said the two cases are very different.
The Van Buren County teacher, Johnny Lee McElroy, 54, remains held under $495,000 bond on nine counts of sexual battery by an authority figure after he reportedly confessed to having a long-term sexual affair with a girl, now 15. He was assigned a preliminary hearing date for next month and has contracted the services of Galligan & Newman for his defense.
McElroy, who had been with the school system since 1998, was a high school teacher who first met his victim a few years back when he taught her in the sixth grade at Van Buren County Middle School. Investigators say the sexual contact between the two happened in numerous places including his classroom during school hours, at the city park and in a moving vehicle. Investigators also say more charges are likely.
McElroy?s arrest came two days before the release of former Centertown Elementary gym teacher Pamela Rogers, who served 198 days of an eight-year sentence in jail for sexual battery by an authority figure on a 13-year-old Centertown student. The timing naturally prompted some to question if McElroy will get the same 198-day jail sentence.
In light of the questions, Potter says the cases are very different, both in the contact between victim and defendant and the evidence prosecutors will have during trial.
?This was a long-term crime, a lot more involved than the two months of the Pam Rogers case,? Potter said. ?The facts in this case are completely different than in the Rogers case. It doesn?t make a difference to us whether the teacher was male or female or how they look.?
While unable to say if a confession was given, sources say McElroy did make an admission against his interest ? something that could be used against him at trial. Rogers did not grant lawmen an interview and, in fact, entered a no-contest plea, never admitting she committed the crime.
The additional leverage of a confession or admission against interest, along with other evidence prosecutors have in the Van Buren County case, could give the state better footing than it had in the Rogers case.
During discovery in the Rogers case, it was learned lawmen had minimal direct evidence linking her to the crime, meaning the case would have likely have been based on the testimony of the victim.
McElroy, who is also a Church of Christ preacher, may face a considerably longer term than Rogers, prosecutors suggest, given the impact of the crime.
?There was a lot of emotional damage done because this was a long-term crime and this child may have long-term issues,? Potter said. ?He could be looking at quite a bit of time.?
