Parents argue boy was chained because he was violent
The defense opened its case Friday and was expected to continue Monday before the case goes to the jury, The Tennessean reported.
Joshua Osborne’s father, James C. Osborne III, 44, and stepmother, Christie Osborne, 30, are on trial on charges of aggravated child neglect filed after the state Department of Children’s Services took the boy into custody in 2004 at the age of 15. The stepmother’s sister was the one who reported the family to authorities.
The teen told jurors Thursday that he sometimes escaped the chains they used to bind him to his bed to sneak out and find food.
He said his parents routinely fed him just soup and water, but occasionally his father would sneak him more food behind his stepmother’s back.
“He’d give me food like sandwiches and chips — actually, not chips, because if you crunch, she’d hear,” he said. “When I was really, really good, and cleaned the house, I would get real food.”
When Joshua entered the courtroom some of the jurors were seen crying. He smiled at them, and some waved at the witness.
Defense lawyers started putting on their witnesses Friday. They have contended that the teen’s low weight is the result of a heart transplant when he was an infant and that the boy was restrained because he was violent.
Joshua testified Thursday that he did try to kill Christie Osborne several times and repeatedly picked fights at school.
“One time I was going to stab her because I didn’t like her,” Joshua said of his stepmother. “I didn’t like it there. She was mean to me. She would beat me, everywhere.”
Joshua’s teacher testified Friday that the stepmother was very concerned about Joshua and his medical problems.
Joshua received a heart transplant at 2 weeks old and has been under special medical care ever since.
Defense attorneys said the fact that his parents’ always took him to his medical appointments is proof they were not treating him cruelly.
After he was removed from the home, Joshua spent three weeks at Vanderbilt University’s Monroe Carell Jr. Children’s Hospital recovering from malnutrition, dehydration and a dangerously low level of minerals in his bloodstream, records show.
“He looked not in any acute distress, but certainly skinny,” testified Dr. Debra Dodd, who has treated Joshua since his birth. “The only thing that has been changed (in treatment since 2004) is his diet. He’s on regular diet. The medication remained the same. I think it rules out all the other explanations for his condition except malnutrition.”
The teenager has nearly doubled his weight since 2004, now weighing almost 100 pounds, according to testimony.
