Skip to content

Auto loan discrimination case goes to mediation again

NASHVILLE, Tenn. Copyright 2006 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. — The two sides in a car loan discrimination case tried in federal court a year ago were referred Thursday to a mediator for a second time to try and reach a settlement.

U.S. District Court Judge Aleta Trauger ended last year’s trial by saying the plaintiffs proved that lending practices of Franklin-based Primus Financial Services were discriminatory against minorities. The two-week trial ended March 16, 2005.

Since then, lawyers for the two sides have negotiated directly and with the help of a federal mediator to try and settle the case.

“We think it is nonsensical to be here after being unable to reach a settlement,” plaintiff lawyer Michael Terry told Trauger at a hearing Thursday. “We are willing to do whatever you instruct us to do.”

Because lawyers on both sides said they had been making progress recently, she referred them back to mediation, which may not begin for about a month.

Plaintiffs in the class action lawsuit claimed Primus’ practice of “marking up” loan interest rates was discriminatory toward black consumers.

Primus, formerly called Primus Automotive Financial Services, is an affiliate of Ford Motor Credit Corp.

Marking up a loan is a practice in which dealers add percentage points of interest to a loan and, in agreement with the finance company, get to keep most of the extra interest money. The plaintiffs claimed that with Primus the loans of black customers were marked up more often and by higher amounts than financing for whites.

Since 1998, there have been several lawsuits filed against auto financing companies, alleging discrimination against blacks. Those suits have resulted in six out-of-court settlements. The lawsuit against Primus, filed in 2002, was the first to go to trial.

The settlements have included the companies placing caps on loan markups and establishing “affirmative lending” programs in which minority customers receive loans with no markups.

Leave a Comment