Skip to content

Less time for the crimeNew state law cuts DUI sentences in half

Less time for the crimeNew state law cuts DUI sentences in half

CURTISS
First-time DUI offenders don?t have to serve as much jail time under a new state law that went into effect at the beginning of the year.

The new law requires those convicted of DUI to serve half the jail time ? 24 hours instead of 48. But the catch is offenders also have to spend 24 hours picking up trash on the side of the road wearing vests that say ?DUI offender.?

The law has received its share of criticism because it?s viewed by some as not being as harsh on those convicted of drinking and driving.

However, state Rep. Charles Curtiss doesn?t buy into that logic.

?I don?t know about you, but I wouldn?t want to be seen on the side of the road by my friends and neighbors picking up trash with a DUI vest,? said Curtiss. ?I think it can serve as a deterrent.?

The new law only applies to people who have been charged with DUI since Jan. 1. Since there?s usually a delay from the time a person is arrested till the time they appear in court, the new sentences have just recently started appearing on court dockets published in the newspaper.

?I don?t think it?s effective. I think it?s a step back,? said General Session Judge Larry Ross, who hands out the local DUI sentences. ?It all hinges on the fact it would embarrass these guys to pick up trash on the side of the road and I don?t know if that?s the case.?

Ross said general sessions judges, the sheriff?s association, and MADD have all spoken out against the new law. He said one aspect of the new law that?s puzzling is offenders are supposed to pick up litter in their home county. This would prevent a Warren County resident who gets a DUI in Nashville from picking up litter in Davidson County.

?I guess that means I have to send about a third of my DUI offenders back to Mexico,? said Ross.

Sheriff Jackie Matheny, who is responsible for supervising the DUI offenders for three, eight-hour shifts of picking up trash, says it will take awhile to work out the program kinks. He said the special ?DUI offender? vests have been ordered but haven?t yet arrived.

Matheny said he?s willing to work to implement the trash pick-up program, but said he doesn?t like the idea of having to use sheriff?s department employees to supervise the DUI offenders.

?It?s hard when the Legislature dumps something in your lap and doesn?t give you the means to pay for it,? said Matheny. ?There?s been a lot of complaining and I don?t know too many sheriffs who are happy about it. I?m going to reserve my judgment until we get it up and running.?

Matheny said organizing three separate times for each DUI offender to work for eight straight hours could become problematic, as well as a considerable expense. In defense of the new program, Matheny said he wasn?t convinced jail time serves as a DUI deterrent.

?We have people in here serving 120 days on their third or fourth DUI and the jail time doesn?t seem to stop them,? said Matheny.

Curtiss indicated there could be some changes to the law during this legislative session that would shift coordinating the program from the sheriff?s department to the county?s litter coordinator.

The old law
DUI offenders were fined $350, forced to serve 48 hours in jail, and spend 11 months, 29 days on probabtion

The new law
DUI offenders are fined $350, must spend 24 hours in jail and spend 24 hours doing community service work, and spend 11-29 on probation

Leave a Comment