Skip to content

CCA wants to eliminate comparison with state prison system

NASHVILLE, Tenn. Copyright 2006 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. — A private prison contractor wants to remove one layer of oversight comparing its services to state-run prisons, saying it is still subject to other steps to make sure it is performing within the law.

A bill passed by a Senate committee Tuesday would eliminate a mid-contract comparison of a prison run by Corrections Corp. of America with two run by the state Department of Corrections.

The Nashville-based corrections company said it pushed for the bill because it duplicates oversight already in place, but opponents said legislators will lose their checks and balances on both state and private prisons.

The bill, sponsored by Senate Majority Leader Ron Ramsey of Blountville, passed the Senate State and Local Government Committee 5-4 along party lines.

The review that Ramsey’s bill would eliminate takes place in the third year of every five-year prison contract. Ramsey said it is unnecessary because the corrections department is already required to do an annual review of its prisons, in addition to other internal oversights.

The review targeted by the bill is in place to ensure privately run prisons deliver services equal to or better than those provided by the corrections department and for at least 5 percent less the cost, as required by state law.

“It’s going to dim the lights and our view of what’s happening isn’t going to be so clear after this is over,” Sen. Doug Jackson, D-Dickson, said before voting against the bill.

Josh Brown, CCA senior director of customer relations, told members of the committee that the company’s services were reviewed and investigated individually under its contract with the state.

“The only way it benefits CCA is it creates more efficiency,” Brown said following the committee hearing. “The department is still going to have the ability to review the services.”

Neither the governor’s staff nor state corrections officials would recommend that the bill be approved or rejected, but Department of Corrections Commissioner George Little said the comparative process had so far proven “very informative.”

Jackson said he was inclined to vote against the bill because the CCA staff had provided no information to senators on how much time or money eliminating the process would save.

Brown said he felt such numbers were unnecessary.

——

See SB1283/HB1818 on the General Assembly Web site at: http://www.legislature.state.tn.us/

Leave a Comment