Skip to content

Aldermen debate administrator?s role

Aldermen debate administrator?s role

KIRBY
Is McMinnville ready for another powerful city administrator? The last five years have left some city officials a bit weary. Before beginning the search for a new city administrator, aldermen questioned the wording of the city administrator?s job description.

As for attendance in the board and committee meetings, the wording states the city administrator ?shall? be heard as to all matters for which he wishes to speak.

?I think that should be ?may? and not ?shall,? said Vice Mayor Patti Nunley in a meeting last week. ?We don?t want the new city administrator to take charge of all meetings. If we replace the wording, that gives the chairman of the meeting the opportunity to acknowledge him.?

After a few looks from the other aldermen, Nunley went on to clarify.

?You think I?m picking,? said Nunley, ?but I?m not. Within legal terms, ?shall? means ?must.? It means that at any time a city administrator wants to take control of a meeting, he ?shall? be heard. He can take control of any meeting he chooses.?

None of the other aldermen or the mayor ?shall? be heard during committee meetings that they are not a member of, added Mayor Royce Davenport. ?It doesn?t say ?shall? for me. If I want to speak, I have to be recognized by the committee. If we change it to ?may? they will still be able to speak but they will have to be recognized first.?

Alderman Bobby Kirby sees it differently.

?If the person has day-to-day activities with the department heads, he needs to be heard, he ?shall? be heard. I don?t think we need to change that,? Kirby said.

Mirroring that belief was Alderman Donald Hillis, ?If he is the city administrator and he has all the authority, I think he ?shall? be heard.?

Speaking on authority, the fact the city administrator has absolute authority to fire a department head is also of concern to some aldermen.

?I think the city administrator should at least inform the board first before a department head is fired,? said Nunley. ?If you choose to give the city administrator that ability, informing the board first would keep them from acting in haste or anger.?

Support for the idea came from Alderman Jimmy Haley who stated, ?How would we know that a department head has been fired if he doesn?t have to bring it to the attention of the board? We won?t know unless the department tells us, but if that?s what you want.?

No fear of that, according to Hillis.

?I think we would all know in about three minutes,? Hillis said.

A city administrator is like a manager of a business. All the employees report to that person. In return, the manager reports to his or her boss, Kirby pointed out.

?It?s a simple chain of command,? said Kirby. ?You can?t cut the legs off the top man. No one will know who to answer to.?

Does the city administrator have too much power?

?I think we are hiring someone to work for the city of McMinnville,? said Nunley. ?I don?t think we are creating a demigod. You guys are giving him the keys and the whip.?

By the end of the meeting, the job description for the next city administrator, wording unchanged, passed the vote with Nunley voicing the only ?no.?

Leave a Comment