Skip to content

Lawmakers begin reviewing eminent domain bills

NASHVILLE — Tennessee lawmakers on Monday began discussing a number of eminent domain bills, most of which would prohibit seizing property for economic development or private use.

Both parties have introduced a flurry of bills following last year’s ruling in which the U.S. Supreme Court found that the city of New London, Conn., had the authority to take homes for a private development project.

Governments have long purchased private property for the construction of roads, bridges, dams, sewer lines and the like. If owners are unwilling to sell, governments can use eminent domain to force sale of the property.

The Supreme Court ruling has prompted Tennessee and some 40 other states to debate putting new restrictions on the practice.

One of the 36 bills before a joint bipartisan committee would require the state or municipality condemning the private property “to pay the owner three times the value of the property as determined by the average of three appraisals.”

The bill’s sponsor, Rep. Frank Niceley, said his legislation would keep the state from “buying too much land” and give the individual being bought out enough money to relocate comfortably.

“It’s a traumatic experience when someone comes in and takes something from you,” said the Strawberry Plains Republican. “I’m not in favor of the state taking any land for economic development.”

Rep. Stacey Campfield, R-Knoxville, is proposing three eminent domain bills. One would allow a 120-day moratorium on the transfer of property from one private entity to another in order to give a committee an opportunity to review the transaction.

He said it would also allow the property owner being approached a chance to try to negotiate a better price, instead of being forced to settle.

Campfield cited the case of a Knoxville family that owned a wrecking company and were threatened with condemnation if they didn’t accept the city’s buyout price.

“We told them no, and the letters started coming about condemning,” said Mary Turner, whose husband inherited the company from his father.

Rather than risk being condemned, Turner said the family sold the company for thousands of dollars less than market value.

“When you have a choice of taking this low ball price, or nothing, it’s not a fair price for the person,” Campfield said.

However, city officials said the Turners were paid 2 percent above the appraised value of their company and were given $20,000 for relocation.

“It was a negotiated sale,” said Knoxville spokeswoman Margie Nichols. “They weren’t forced out.”

Gov. Phil Bredesen says he supports exploring eminent domain options.

“I do think that in light of the Supreme Court decision that some limitations on the use of eminent domain for private purposes is appropriate, and is something that I hope this General Assembly will talk about and see if there is something they would like to do.”

——

On the Net:

See SB3237/HB3302; HB2682/SB3160; HB2683/SB3158; HB2679/SB2681 Tennessee Legislature: http://www.legislature.state.tn.us/

Leave a Comment