Undercover tape gives details on Tennessee Waltz payouts
Using a miniature camera hidden in his shirt, Joseph Carroll, posing as corrupt businessman Joe Carson, recorded conversations over a two-day period in a 3.5 hour of video obtained by The Commercial Appeal.
In the video, Carroll instructs Charles Love, a lobbyist and former member of Hamilton County Board of Education, to deliver the $2,500 to Miller.
Miller has long acknowledged taking $1,000 as a campaign contribution and said it was “an absolute lie” that he accepted any more. He has not been charged with wrongdoing.
Standing by a statement he gave last fall, Miller said Love gave him $1,100 in cash. He said he returned $100 and reported the rest as a campaign contribution.
The money Love handed him in an envelope was far short of $2,500, he said.
“Charles Love is lying,” said Miller, a democrat.
Miller said Love could have stolen any extra money the FBI gave him. Love, who pleaded guilty last August to extortion and bribery, has admitted skimming FBI money intended for another Waltz target.
Love’s lawyer, Lee Davis, declined comment, saying only that his client has given a complete statement to authorities.
In the video, after Carroll is shown giving Love instructions, the two appear beneath a street lamp, and Carroll asks Love if he made the delivery.
“You gave him all 25?”
“Yeah,” Love answers. “…He knows where it came from.”
The tapes, recorded Nov. 18-19, 2004, in East Tennessee, also show then-state Sen. John Ford and then-Rep. Chris Newton discussing plans with Carroll.
Newton, a Cleveland Republican, pleaded guilty and has been sentenced to a year in prison. Ford has pleaded not guilty and awaits trial.
Newton and Ford are among seven officials — including three other current or former state lawmakers — indicted in connection with the federal undercover sting operation that became public in May.
The tapes are just part of an estimated 3,000 hours of video and phone tap evidence.
Also in the video, Ford appears to tell Carroll he’s added language to a legislative bill that Carroll said was crucial to give his company advantage over potential business competitors. That company — E-Cycle Management Inc. — turned out to be a phony company set up by the FBI for the sting.
Carroll tells Ford he’s recruited help from Sen. Ward Crutchfield, D-Chattanooga but he still fears the bill will face opposition. Crutchfield has been charged and has pleaded not guilty.
Ford then tells Carroll he’ll deal with any opposition, but doesn’t say how.
By the date of the dinner, Ford had already accepted $20,000 from E-Cycle and would go on to take another $35,000, according to his indictment.
Miller said he still doesn’t know why the FBI targeted him. The Justice Department allows agents to offer bribes to a public official only after first establishing predication, or evidence of a predisposition to corruption.
“I’ve asked myself that question: Why was I approached?” Miller said. “I can’t answer that question why. Was I predisposed to something? No.”
Carroll himself seemed puzzled by Miller.
“I can’t get a good read on him,” he told Love.
