Skip to content

Local officials gear up to fight changes to open meetings law

NASHVILLE — A state association representing county officials says a proposal to update the state’s open meetings law would have “unbearable consequences” for local elected officials.

Proponents of the legislation, meanwhile, argue that the counties either misunderstand the proposal or are misleading lawmakers in an attempt to repeal open meetings rules already on the books.

In a newsletter distributed last week, the Tennessee County Services Association railed against what would be the first overhaul of the state’s “Sunshine in Government” law since it was passed in 1974.

“The enforcement provisions and other aspects of this act will have a substantial chilling affect on the activities and decision making of governmental bodies,” the newsletter said.

Frank Gibson, executive director of the Tennessee Coalition for Open Government, said the proposals would add teeth to the law, but would not require big changes in how officials currently conduct business.

Under the proposed changes, city councils and county commissions could get hit with a $50 fine and attorneys’ fees for knowingly violating open meetings rules.

The bill also would clarify rules for when and how governments can hold a closed meeting, how notice of meetings should be given and what activities constitute and official meeting.

The open government coalition was created in 2003 to protect and improve Tennessee’s public access laws. Members include the Tennessee Press Association, the state’s major daily newspapers, the Tennessee Association of Broadcasters, The Associated Press and Common Cause of Tennessee.

The group found 115 alleged violations between January 2003 and October 2005, including an average of one a week for the first 10 months of last year.

The County Services Association argues that figure has to be seen in context: The 115 alleged violations make up less than a fraction of 1 percent of all meetings held in Tennessee over those three years.

“Local officials need to be complimented for already meeting a high threshold,” said David Seivers, the association’s executive director.

The association argues that the bill would place an undue burden on officials to prove that they did not violate open meetings rules and that incidental meetings between officials could lead to frivolous lawsuits.

“For local elected officials, this bill puts additional, unbearable consequences on them in what is already a difficult job,” the newsletter said.

Gibson said the bill would dispel the myth that members of a local government body can meet in private as long as they don’t vote on anything. Existing law states that two members of the same body cannot privately discuss public matters.

The newsletter warns that officials would have to prove their innocence if they are seen at together at a public meeting.

“If you attend the same church, eat together, fish together or happen to be seen chatting at the same Friday night high school football game, you could be put in a position of being taken to court,” the newsletter said.

Gibson called that scenario wildly unlikely.

“It’s ludicrous to suggest that somebody is going to sue for something like that, and even more ludicrous to think they would win,” he said.

Nevertheless, a committee of the Bedford County Board of Commissioners last week voted to send a resolution opposing the open meetings proposal to the full commission, the Shelbyville Times-Gazette reported. Commissioner Roger Brothers described the bill as “the biggest bunch of hogwash that ever was.”

The bill’s House sponsor, Judiciary Chairman Joe Fowlkes, held a meeting on the measure late last week and said feelings “cooled off a little bit” after heated exchanges earlier in the process.

The Cornersville Democrat has asked for local officials to submit proposed changes to the bill by this week and plans to draft a compromise version by the end of the week.

Conspicuously absent from last week’s meeting were some of the bill’s most vocal opponents.

“At this meeting they were supposed to come forward with their list of concerns, but they were not there, and we don’t know why,” Gibson said.

After discussions with officials representing Tennessee municipalities and school boards, sponsors decided to address some concerns about the burden of proof standard, Gibson said.

Seivers said his group will evaluate the next version of the bill, but that they chose not to comment on piecemeal adjustments to the proposal.

House Majority Leader Kim McMillan described the proposal as “make the law more understandable and try to deal with it in a comprehensive way so that local governments would understand what meetings were open, what meetings weren’t and how they had to conduct themselves in accordance with the law.”

The Clarksville Democrat acknowledged that there has been “some resistance” to the measure, but said she is confident that the difference can be hammered out.

Also last week, an Attorney General’s opinion that it would be unconstitutional to place the Legislature under the open meetings act led to several newspaper to editorialize that lawmakers should consider proposing a constitutional amendment.

“I’m going to let somebody else fight that battle,” said Fowlkes. “I’ve got my hands full with this bill.”

——

See SB2471/HB2495 on the General Assembly Web site at: http://www.legislature.state.tn.us

——

On the Net:

Tennessee County Services Association: http://www.tncounties.org

Tennessee Coalition for Open Government: http://www.tcog.info

Leave a Comment