Feds decline new environmental study of state coal mining
NASHVILLE — The federal Office of Surface Mining has declined Gov. Phil Bredesen’s request for a new environmental review of Tennessee’s coal mining operations.
In a letter sent Thursday, OSM Acting Director Brent Wahlquist said that Bredesen’s request was “neither warranted nor appropriate.”
Bredesen had requested the review in January, citing “significant and growing controversy over the past few years over coal mining in Tennessee.” Bredesen wanted a new environmental impact statement to supplant one conducted shortly after the federal government took over the state’s coal-mining program in 1985.
In a follow-up to Bredesen’s Jan. 9 letter, state Deputy Commissioner for Environment Paul Sloan said the request was “based on our view that environmental regulation should be based on best available scientific and technological resources and should be developed in a process that is open to the affected interest groups and the public.”
The Office of Surface Mining turned back the request, saying that if the state wants to re-evaluate environmental standards, it should do so itself.
“Of the 25 coal-producing states, Tennessee is one of only two that do not have primacy,” Wahlquist said. “By implementing a state program, the citizens and government of Tennessee could directly address the concerns raised in your letter in ways that best meet the needs and interests of Tennessee.”
By taking back primary regulation of coal mining, Tennessee would be eligible for annual grants to pay half of regulatory costs and federal Abandoned Mine Land money, Wahlquist said.
“With the growing interest by the citizens of Tennessee in the impacts and regulation of coal mining in your state, the time may be right for Tennessee to rejoin the community of states that regulate coal mining themselves,” he wrote.
A relatively small-scale coal producer, Tennessee in 2004 extracted about 2.9 million tons of coal from 12 underground and 20 surface mines, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration.
Bredesen’s spokeswoman said the administration is disappointed with the OSM response, and that the governor and state environmental officials are “conferring on next steps.”
——
On the Net:
Office of Surface Mining: http://www.osmre.gov/
