Tennessee has been using tax incentives at heart of court case
The court considered a case that could do that on Wednesday. The issue stems from whether the tax breaks Ohio used in 2001 to persuade DaimlerChrysler AG to build a Jeep assembly plant there were constitutional.
The decision could have national impact because nearly every state, including Tennessee, uses lucrative tax incentives to lure companies to relocate or expand.
Tennessee alone has offered in the last several years hundreds of millions of dollars in incentives to companies like Nissan, FedEx and International Paper, helping earn the state a high ranking in an industry trade magazine that monitors corporate relocations and expansions.
Nashville, in fact, has ranked No. 1 the past two years by Expansion Management, a 45,000-circulation magazine read by corporate executives and real estate professionals. Other Tennessee cities on the magazine’s most recent “America’s Hottest 50 Cities” list were Memphis at No. 7, Knoxville at No. 9 and Jackson at No. 42.
Nashville lawyer Mike Stewart has filed “friends of the court” briefs for the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the chambers of Kentucky, Michigan, Ohio and Tennessee.
He and others say international competition has made tax incentives a critical tool for attracting high-wage jobs.
Critics, however, contend that taxpayers should not have to pay for private businesses wanting to expand or move their operations.
The law was challenged by taxpayers who say that state bidding wars over car plants and other development have gotten out of hand, with taxpayers footing the bill.
The 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati agreed and struck down Ohio’s practice, saying it hindered interstate commerce because the incentives are available only to businesses that invest in Ohio.
The ruling applied in the states in the circuit, including Tennessee.
Bill Fox, economics professor at the University of Tennessee, said the state has been “relatively aggressive” in using tax concessions and could be at a disadvantage if other states were able to offer incentives and it wasn’t.
“If the Supreme Court were to find it unconstitutional, at least it would apply to everyone, level the playing field,” Fox said. “Taxes do matter in location decisions, but taxes alone aren’t going to drive that decision.”
Tennessee offered nearly $200 million in incentives to Nissan Motor Co. to relocate its North American headquarters to the state last year, when the state revamped its rules to make it easier to offer incentives to companies relocating their headquarters to Tennessee.
The headquarters tax incentive was created in the late 1990s — aimed at FedEx Corp. — and has since been given to International Paper and Medtronics in Memphis and to Caterpillar Financial in Nashville.
International Paper announced in August it was moving its global headquarters to Memphis from Stamford, Conn.
Fox said that even if the Supreme Court ruled in favor of taxpayers in the case, the state would still be permitted to give certain kinds of concessions but would likely have to structure them differently.
He also said some members of Congress would probably try to change the law to try to defer or limit the impact of the decision.
“I think there’s some opposition to granting concessions,” he said. “But the reality is in a Republican Congress that’s shown itself anxious to reduce tax burdens, it doesn’t seem unreasonable.”
