Skip to content

Ethics scandals spanned parties, branches of government in 2005

NASHVILLE, Tenn. Copyright 2005 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. — It can take a scandal to force lawmakers into thinking about writing laws to combat corruption, and Tennessee had several in 2005.

Chief among them was the federal investigation dubbed Tennessee Waltz that led to bribery charges in May against five current or former legislators, as well as a lobbyist and a political operative described by prosecutors as “bag men.”

John Ford, a Memphis Democrat and the most prominent target of the sting, resigned from his state Senate seat shortly after the indictment. He has pleaded not guilty to taking $55,000 in bribes from undercover FBI agents posing as lobbyists. His trial is tentatively scheduled for Feb. 6.

The arrests marked the highest-profile corruption indictments in Tennessee since the 1990 Rocky Top gambling scandal that led to several indictments and suicides by two public officials.

“Concerns about ethics tend to be episodic, and those episodes are stimulated when there are horror strikes,” said Bruce Oppenheimer, a political science professor at Vanderbilt University. “And, of course, Tennessee Waltz was a real horror story.”

Ford’s consulting work while still a member of the Legislature also contributed to new ethics laws prohibiting lawmakers from lobbying or consulting for companies that do business with the state.

But the Tennessee Waltz arrests came late in the legislative session, so lawmakers are set to take a more sweeping approach to improving General Assembly ethics in a special session that starts Jan. 10.

Tennessee’s ethics laws are among the weakest in the country, according to the nonpartisan Center for Public Integrity. Lawmakers do not have to disclose their sources of income, and lobbyists do not have to report how much they spend wining and dining politicians.

“Legislators don’t want to feel their hands tied, but you’ve got to balance that with the public’s right to know,” said Leah Rush, the center’s director for state projects.

A draft version of proposed ethics legislation covers three broad areas: the creation of an independent ethics commission; increased disclosure and regulation of lobbyists; and changes to campaign finance laws.

For Tennessee lobbyists, there’s a certain irony that the current initiatives were born out of the Tennessee Waltz sting.

“None of the ethics legislation that’s pending would have had any effect on that investigation,” said Mark Greene, chairman of the Tennessee Lobbyists Association. “We have bribery laws on the books, and it’s always been illegal to hand over bags of cash.”

Nevertheless, Greene said, most lobbyists acknowledge their image has taken a hit from the sting, and improving public perception through ethics legislation “can’t help but be good in the long run.”

The executive branch wasn’t left untouched by ethical problems in 2005.

Gov. Phil Bredesen’s administration and associates of former Gov. Don Sundquist were battling their own sets of ethics issues as the year ended.

Bredesen, a Democrat, earlier this month denounced “a pattern of cronyism” within the Tennessee Highway Patrol after an investigation found 41 troopers and staffers had criminal or driving violation histories. The charges ranged in severity and included aggravated assault and reckless endangerment.

The commander of the Highway Patrol, Col. Lynn Pitts, was forced to resign after The Tennessean of Nashville reported that he tried to purchase a boat seized by troopers and put up for sale as surplus state property.

Also this year, longtime Sundquist associate John Stamps pleaded guilty to tax evasion and making false statements to secure a state contract. Joanna Ediger, a former state grants director, was convicted and began serving her three-year sentence for fraud in June. Al Ganier, another friend of the Republican former governor, has yet to go to trial.

Bob Davis, chairman of the Tennessee Republican Party, said current ethics concerns should be of greater concern than those related to past administrations.

“Right now, you’ve got a mess in this administration. You have an ethics scandal that’s still brewing down there,” he said. “We’ve got to get beyond this; it’s an embarrassment for the whole state.”

State Rep. Frank Buck was among lawmakers pushing for more meaningful changes to ethics laws before news of the FBI sting broke. The Dowelltown Democrat said he was “fought tooth and nail” on proposals for more disclosures on lobbyists.

“And then the arrests happened in Tennessee Waltz, and now they’re coming around to that,” he said. “It’s amazing what a few arrests will do.”

Buck is still pushing for full accounting of legislative votes and access to all meetings.

“It’s the public’s business, and it should be conducted in the public view,” he said. “Going to a restaurant and making their agreements on the budget, now that ain’t right, and it ain’t never been right.”

Democratic Party spokesman Will Pinkston predicted there won’t be much political fallout for either party from the ethics scandals. “This isn’t a partisan issue,” he said. “This is viewed as a problem with the institution of government.”

Pinkston said there will no doubt be some tussling over the final ethics bill, but the two parties have already reached a general consensus on what should be done — and nobody wants to be seen as dragging their feet on the issues.

Vanderbilt’s Oppenheimer has a more fundamental recommendation for fighting corruption in state government: Establish a full-time Legislature — and pay lawmakers accordingly. Tennessee lawmakers are paid $16,500 a year.

“The people are not willing to pay their public officials the salaries that are appropriate for those positions,” he said. “You get what you pay for.”

Proposed Tennessee ethics bill at a glance
Highlights of ethics bill to be considered during a special legislative session beginning Jan. 10:

— Creates a six-member independent ethics commission. The governor appoints two members and the speakers pick two each from a list of three submitted by the caucuses.

— Bans cash campaign contributions to candidates and political action committees.

— Each caucus of the General Assembly must disclose a quarterly list of its contributors and expenditures to the registry of election finance.

— Each gubernatorial candidate and such candidate’s committees that receive at least 10 percent of the vote in the general election will be audited.

— No complaints will be accepted or initiated by the ethics commission against a candidate 30 days before the primary and general elections.

— Employers of lobbyists are allowed to provide items such as entertainment and food for lawmakers and officials as long as it doesn’t exceed $50; anything over that will have to be disclosed to the registry of election finance.

— No lobbyist can serve as a member of the state election commission or any county election commission.

— All meetings of the General Assembly are open to the public if a quorum of lawmakers is present.

— In order to make the expense and mileage information of the members of the General Assembly more accessible to the public, the office of management information systems will post contact information for the director of the office of legislative administration on the General Assembly Web site.

— A person convicted of a crime in another state will be banned from holding any office under Tennessee’s laws and constitution.

Leave a Comment