Skip to content

Harwell tells Bredesen to address ‘lapses of leadership’

NASHVILLE, Tenn. Copyright 2005 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. ? State Rep. Beth Harwell, a potential candidate for governor next year, on Tuesday called on Gov. Phil Bredesen to address “embarrassing lapses of leadership” within his administration.

The Nashville Republican wrote in a letter to Bredesen that “it would be incumbent upon you to clean up your own house first” before the Legislature goes into a special session on ethics next month.

“Tennesseans are looking for real assurance that trust is being restored to their state government,” Harwell said. “We want an explanation as to why you have not provided the kind of leadership it takes to resolve in our state’s government and in the governor’s office.”

Bredesen’s spokeswoman, Lydia Lenker, said the governor was traveling and unavailable for comment. Lenker said she had not yet seen Harwell’s letter.

Harwell said in an interview Tuesday that she does not plan to announce her decision about whether she will run for governor until after the holidays. Harwell, the former chairwoman of the state Republican party and a state lawmaker since 1989, announced in September that she would not run for U.S. Sen. Bill Frist’s open seat.

Harwell said “a good start” would be for Bredesen to return campaign contributions made by members of the Tennessee Highway Patrol and their families. Allegations of political favoritism and mismanagement at the patrol and the state Department of Safety culminated in the resignation of three top officials earlier this month.

A Tennessean investigation has shown that two-thirds of patrol officers proposed for promotions under Bredesen had made campaign donations or had relatives or patrons who did. Of those, half were recommended over troopers with better scores on impartial exams.

The newspaper has also linked Deputy Gov. Dave Cooley, the No. 2 man in state government and a longtime Bredesen associate, to promotions and other personnel moves inside the Highway Patrol.

Harwell stopped short of calling for Cooley’s resignation, but wrote to the governor that “you have some clear and difficult personnel decisions to make over the next few days, including one of your closest and most trusted advisers, the deputy governor.”

Cooley could not be reached for comment.

Bredesen reprimanded Cooley in September 2004 after Cooley handed a trooper his business card during a traffic stop. The state attorney general said no criminal charges were warranted in the case.

State Democratic Party spokesman Will Pinkston said Harwell’s letter was written for partisan purposes and that Cooley was merely doing his job when he made personnel recommendations at the Highway Patrol.

“It’s absurd to criticize the chief operating officer of the state for getting involved in important personnel decisions…,” Pinkston said. “It’s not uncommon for the deputy governor to have an input in personnel decisions in any agency, particularly in high-level positions. That function has been carried out by deputy governors for decades.”

Bredesen earlier this month suggested that one way to make the patrol more efficient may be to return captains to the civil service ranks, rather than have them continue to be politically appointed.

“Let’s just have more professional positions in there, where people can have their say and some protection against political interference,” he said.

For Harwell, the promotions at the Highway Patrol are “among a litany of issues” that need to be addressed by Bredesen.

“There has been much finger pointing, assignment of blame, and embarrassing lapses of leadership,” she wrote. “However, accountability rests with you and the charge of your office.”

Leave a Comment