Tennessee public defenders say they’re overloaded with cases
“There’s a high percentage of indigent defendants not receiving effective assistance from counsel because public defenders are overloaded,” said Gary Anderson, a University of Tennessee law professor.
“Caseloads keep increasing every year and they (public defenders) don’t seem to be getting much more in the way of money or staff (from state lawmakers),” he said.
Public defenders were appointed to 183,136 criminal cases during fiscal year 2005, a 6.5 percent increase over last year, according to an annual report from the Tennessee District Public Defenders Conference.
The cases involved 313,400 charges, a 5.6 percent increase over last year’s level. Of those charges, public defenders were able to close out cases involving 292,822 charges, said Jeff Henry, executive director of the Public Defenders Conference.
“That means we started this fiscal year with a backlog of 20,518 charges left over from previous years,” Henry said in a released statement Friday. “An understaffed criminal justice system is a detriment for all Tennesseans. Every Tennessean has the right to feel protected by a criminal justice system that meets the needs of all our citizens.”
Each public defender lawyer was appointed to an average of 911 cases last fiscal year.
Henry said it helped that state legislators signed off on 23 new public defenders in 2004 though the hires still fall short of the number of positions recommended by the state comptroller.
A recent study by the state comptroller says the Public Defenders Conference should employ an additional 120 lawyers to adequately handle the state’s indigent defense caseload, Henry said.
Anderson said for years state public defenders have been overloaded with cases, spending only a few minutes with each in some circumstances before they’re processed in court.
“Indigent defendants are not the kind of constituency most legislators pay attention to in this state,” Anderson said. “It’s the lack of political clout that I think causes this problem.”
