ALL BUSINESS: Limited results for some activist investors
NEW YORK Copyright 2005 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. ? When major shareholders attack corporate leaders over how they run their businesses and demand big changes, the ultimate goal usually is to send the stock price higher. But this year, that tactic doesn’t seem to be working.
While big investors are trying to shake up some of the nation’s largest companies including Blockbuster Inc., Time Warner Inc., General Motors Corp., Calpine Inc. and OfficeMax Inc., their activism hasn’t yet turned into a bonanza for those holding the stock.
Those making all the noise ? everyone from hedge funds to well-known financiers ? are sure to say there are no quick fixes in corporate America. That may be true, but it still doesn’t explain how some companies not only have seen their stock prices plunge since the activists got involved but also are in worse financial health.
It is something to keep in mind given all the publicity lately that large shareholders have been getting for blasting companies. When big investors loudly demand change, other stockholders tend to hope that the activists will get what they want.
Several things are fueling a recent rise of activism. Some want a say over CEO pay, while others disagree with corporate spending. Many want companies to be more generous in doling out cash through dividends or stock repurchase plans.
Yet while they all share a similar purpose ? to make money by raising the stock price as a way of boosting their own performance, which helps them retain and gain new clients ? the results have proven disappointing.
Maybe that’s why financier investor Carl Icahn stepped up his attack on Time Warner in recent weeks, launching a full-blown proxy fight to control a majority of the media giant’s 14-member board and pressing the company to engage in further restructuring.
It’s the latest chapter in his confrontation with the New York-based company, which began in August. He has pushed for the company to increase its share repurchase plan ? which it did, boosting it from $5 billion to $12.5 billion last month ? and wants it to spin off its cable television unit.
Icahn, who together with an affiliated group of investors owns nearly 3 percent of Time Warner stock, has also been very public in discussing his displeasure with the company, including sending letters to shareholders detailing his complaints.
But Time Warner stock has barely budged since Icahn launched his campaign on Aug. 15, when it closed at $18.40 a share. It now trades at around $18 a piece.
It wouldn’t be the first time this year that his activist role hasn’t paid off, at least yet. Icahn owns a 10 percent stake at Blockbuster and captured three board seats earlier this year after criticizing management for its strategy and spending habits as the movie-rental chain tried to take on competitors.
But since he went after Blockbuster management last spring, business at the Dallas-based company has fallen off and its stock price has slumped. Blockbuster shares are now trading around $4 each, less than half of what it was when Icahn began his fight.
Things at General Motors have gone from bad to worse since billionaire investor Kirk Kerkorian announced he had amassed almost a 10 percent stake in the automaker and indicated his firm might seek a seat on GM’s board of directors.
Profits have tumbled, as has Detroit-based GM’s U.S. market share. All that has come despite an aggressive promotional campaign that offered vehicles at deep discounts. Last month, the company expanded its cost-cutting plan by announcing its intentions to slash 30,000 jobs and close nine North American factories. There has even been some talk in financial circles about the possibility of GM filing for bankruptcy.
With its prospects looking grim, GM shares last month sank to their lowest level since 1987, though they have gained almost $2 since to now trade at around $22 each. Kerkorian is deep in the red on a bet that GM could turn itself around ? he has posted paper losses of more than $300 million on the more than $1 billion he has invested in GM since June.
Of course, there is always the chance that things at these companies could have been a lot worse had the activist investors not gotten involved. They like to argue that they want companies to get leaner and meaner, which takes some time to accomplish.
For the rest of investors, that only leaves them one choice: How long they are willing to wait for that to happen.
‘
Rachel Beck is the national business columnist for The Associated Press. Write to her at rbeck(at)ap.org
