My Turn: Real Supreme Court battle looms
In case you missed it, in the 24/7 media coverage of Hurricanes Katrina and Rita, the Senate Judiciary Committee has voiced its approval of Judge John Roberts to be the 17th Chief Justice of the United States.
The vote Thursday was 13 to 5 in favor of the president’s nominee.?Predictably, all 10 Republicans approved him, while the Democrats split 3 to 5. Apparently, the “thoughtful three”, Patrick Leahy, Russ Feingold, and Herbert Kohl, voted their hopes and not their fears in their approval of Judge Roberts. However, the “fearful five”, Joseph Biden, Richard Durbin, Dianne Feinstein, Ted Kennedy, and Charles Schumer, voted their fears in rejecting Judge Roberts.
Democratic senators voting no did so only after posturing and pontificating for the media and their constituents. Those voting yes, from both parties, seemed to me to be more thoughtful and rational in citing their reasons for recommending the confirmation of Judge Roberts.
Clearly, the stakes are high any time the United States Senate is called upon to exercise its Constitutional rights and duties of “advice and consent” to the president on Supreme Court nominees. They are especially high when it is the nominee for Chief Justice.
Led by the ailing, but active Republican Senator Arlen Specter and ranking Democrat Patrick Leahy, the Senate Judiciary Committee has done its work well, and in a reasonably fair and dignified way with Judge Roberts.
Now the battle scene shifts to the full Senate, where Judge Roberts seems likely to win bipartisan approval. The only question seems to be: How broad will that bipartisan support be?
Given his supreme intellect, talent, education, experience, and expertise, I believe Judge Roberts deserves a substantial majority of full Senate votes for his confirmation as the next Chief Justice.
Unfortunately, some Democrats, whose disdain for President Bush is visceral, will vote against Judge Roberts, just to vent their frustration with the president.
Despite their begrudging praise for Judge Roberts, they will, like the afore- mentioned “fearful five”, cloak their rationalizations in vague, but shrill assertions that this demonstrably decent man is somehow a potential threat to the Constitution he will swear to uphold, and the nation he is sure to serve for several decades to come.
Whatever the outcome of the full Senate vote on Judge Roberts, the real battle is yet to come. After all, Judge Roberts is, by his own assurances, no ideologue.
By judicial tone and temperament he appears to be closer to his mentor and lifelong friend, the late Chief Justice William Rehnquist, than to anyone else on the Supreme Court.
However, once President Bush nominates a replacement for retiring Associate Justice Sandra Day O’Connor, the feeding frenzy will return with a vengeance.
Conservatives hope, and liberals fear, that President Bush will nominate another conservative for the Supreme Court. If so, expect all parties to the conflict to fight “tooth and nail” for their will to prevail.
Thomas B. Vaughn is a professor at Motlow College and co-host of “Viewpoints,” a show that airs on WCPI 91.3 FM.
