Skip to content

Appeals court overturns judge’s injunction on airlift wing

NASHVILLE (AP) — The 6th U.S. Circuit of Appeals on Thursday overturned a judge’s temporary injunction that would have prevented the Pentagon from recommending in a report to President Bush that the Tennessee Air National Guard’s 118th Airlift Wing be relocated.

U.S. District Judge Robert Echols granted the injunction on Wednesday because the state said there would be “irreparable harm” if the process is allowed to continue “without the state getting judicial review.”

Last month, the independent Base Realignment and Closure Commission voted to send the 118th Airlift Wing’s eight C-130 transport planes to bases in Illinois and Kentucky and its medical squadron to Texas. The Nashville-based 118th has about 1,200 personnel, many of whom would lose their positions, officials said.

On Thursday, the appeals court ruled that “placing the commission and the president in this position is fundamentally antithetical to the proper operation of the BRAC, and that harm cannot be avoided unless the injunction is stayed now.”

State officials said the Department of Justice appealed the ruling. As it stands, the 118th can be included in the report that’s scheduled to be reviewed by Bush soon.

Meanwhile, the state is continuing a lawsuit challenging the move. The lawsuit contends it’s against the law for an Air National Guard unit to be relocated or withdrawn from a state without consent or approval from the governor, who acts as commander in chief of the state’s Guard forces.

“This is not some major setback in the cause,” Bredesen said Thursday. “The lawsuit is still very much active.”

Also Thursday, the Bush administration asked the Supreme Court to intervene and protect the federal panel’s closing and realignment recommendations because of the number of courts around the country filing lawsuits to protect their guard units.

Whenever Bush looks at the panel’s list, he has pledged to give it to Congress without making any changes. Congress then can vote the entire list up or down, but may not modify it.

Other states that have gone to court over the military realignment are Illinois, Massachusetts, Missouri, New Jersey and Pennsylvania.

Leave a Comment