Judge grants injuction to halt closing of Nashville air wing
The state asked U.S. District Judge Robert Echols for the injunction last Friday because they said there would be “irreparable harm” if the process is allowed to continue “without the state getting judicial review.”
Last month, the independent Base Realignment and Closure Commission voted to send the 118th Airlift Wing’s eight C-130 transport planes to bases in Illinois and Kentucky and its medical squadron to Texas. The Nashville-based 118th has a personnel of about 1,200, many of whom would lose their positions, officials said.
“Today’s decision is a clear victory for the 118th Airlift Wing, the governor and the state of Tennessee,” state Attorney General Paul Summers said Wednesday.
Bush is expected to review BRAC’s recommendations soon. If he does, the 118th won’t be included.
“Today’s decision means the BRAC cannot include the transfer of eight C-130 airplanes from the 118th to other National Guard units,” Summers said.
Early last month, Bredesen filed a federal lawsuit challenging the move, contending it’s against the law for an Air National Guard unit to be relocated or withdrawn from a state without consent or approval from the governor, who acts as commander-in-chief of the state’s Guard forces.
Several other governors have filed similar lawsuits and also appear to be having success. Last month, a federal judge ruled in favor of Pennsylvania’s governor, saying the Pentagon’s recommendation to close a National Guard Base there was “null and void.”
On Wednesday, the state of Connecticut obtained a preliminary injunction concerning a National Guard unit there.
“This is a great ruling for Tennessee,” Bredesen said in a statement. “It absolutely underscores the vital role the 118th plays in the safety and security of our state and its citizens.”
Bredesen has emphasized he needs the 118th’s airplanes in times of crises, citing their current use to aid victims of Hurricane Katrina on the Gulf Coast.
“You need look no further than the tragedy unfolding in the wake of Hurricane Katrina to understand just how critical this unit is to Tennessee’s response to emergencies both at home and beyond our borders,” he said Wednesday.
In his ruling, Echols said he made his decision based on the “governor’s likelihood of success on the merits of his constitutional and statutory claims, the irreparable injury he faces, the harm imposing injunctive relief would cause the defendants and the public interest.”
U.S. Rep. Jim Cooper, D-Tenn., lauded the decision and said it would hold up on appeal. “This isn’t any quick opinion, it’s 28 pages long. I think (Judge Echols) is ready for this to stand up all the way to the Supreme Court.”
Cooper joined the other four Democratic congressmen from Tennessee in filing an amicus brief on the governor’s behalf, said the Pentagon’s recommendation to realign the base was politically motivated. “All we’re asking is that the law of the land be upheld and that should be more important than pleasing Donald Rumsfeld,” he said.
Summers said federal officials could appeal the judge’s ruling. Federal attorneys did not immediately return a phone call seeking comment.
